Universal basic income discussed as AI raises job-loss fears

-

Concerns about automation and employment have grown as AI systems spread across sectors from professional services to customer support, prompting warnings that some roles may shrink or disappear. That has renewed debate about how the welfare system should respond if large numbers of workers need to retrain or move sectors.

The latest intervention came from Jason Stockwood, the UK’s investment minister, who said ministers were considering how to provide a “soft landing” for people in industries that may be heavily affected by AI.

Calls for a ‘soft landing’ for affected workers

Stockwood indicated that income support and retraining would both be part of any serious response to disruption. He said the government needed a plan for sectors that could decline as AI capabilities improve.

HRreview Logo

Get our essential weekday HR news and updates.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Keep up with the latest in HR...
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
Optin_date
This field is hidden when viewing the form

 

“Undoubtedly we’re going to have to think really carefully about how we soft-land those industries that go away, so some sort of UBI, some sort of life-long learning mechanism as well, so people can retrain,” he told the Financial Times. He added that people in government were talking about the idea.

Universal basic income (UBI) refers to a regular, unconditional cash payment to individuals regardless of employment status. Advocates argue it provides a financial floor and simplifies welfare. Critics question affordability and warn it could weaken incentives to work.

The comments are notable because the current government has previously played down the idea. Before entering office, Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer said he was not drawn to UBI as a response to AI, arguing instead for retraining and reskilling so workers could move into new roles.

Warnings about disruption from AI

Debate around UBI has intensified as senior figures in technology and politics warn of labour market disruption. Dario Amodei, chief executive of AI company Anthropic, has cautioned that AI could cause “unusually painful” changes in jobs markets and described advanced systems as a broad substitute for human labour in some tasks.

He warned that lower-skilled workers could be pushed into insecure, low-paid work if transitions are not managed well. Such statements have added urgency to policy discussions about safety nets and reskilling.

In the UK, London Mayor Sadiq Khan recently said AI could usher in a period of significant job losses in parts of the capital, particularly in white-collar sectors. His comments reflected concern that professional roles once considered secure may also be exposed.

At the same time, ministers have tried to strike a balanced tone. Liz Kendall has acknowledged that some jobs will disappear because of AI but argued that new roles are also likely to emerge. She said the government would support people to adapt and would not leave communities to cope alone.

UBI in the UK context

Universal basic income has been debated in the UK for years but has never been rolled out nationally. The most prominent recent pilot was in Wales, where a scheme launched in 2022 provided regular payments to young people leaving care to test the impact on stability, wellbeing and life chances.

That pilot was limited in scale and targeted at a specific group rather than the whole population. Evaluations have focused on whether guaranteed income improves housing security, education participation and mental health.

Supporters of wider UBI argue that AI could accelerate the need for such models if employment becomes more volatile. They say a guaranteed income could give people breathing space to retrain, start businesses or take on caring responsibilities.

Opponents point to the fiscal cost. A nationwide UBI at a meaningful level would require tens of billions of pounds annually, depending on design. There are also debates about whether targeted support and active labour market policies deliver better value.

Funding and fairness debates

Stockwood has previously floated the idea that technology firms benefiting from AI-driven productivity could contribute more through taxation. He has also spoken in the past about inequality risks if the gains from AI are concentrated among a small group of owners and investors.

His background outside politics has shaped some of those views. Before entering government he worked in the technology and travel sectors and has spoken about social mobility and regional inequality, drawing on his upbringing in Grimsby.

While he has stepped back from earlier calls for wealth taxes since joining government, his comments signal ongoing concern about how the benefits of AI are distributed.

Focus on retraining likely to continue

Even among those open to UBI, retraining remains central to policy thinking. Lifelong learning, adult skills programmes and closer links between employers and training providers are frequently cited as more politically and fiscally realistic than unconditional income for all.

The debate matters for employers and workforce planners because it shapes how transitions are supported. If workers feel they have some security during change, they may be more willing to retrain or move sectors.

For now, universal basic income remains a topic of discussion rather than firm policy. But as AI adoption grows and evidence on job impact accumulates, experts say pressure is likely to build for clearer plans on how to protect livelihoods as well as promote innovation.

Managing Editor at Black | Website

William Furney is a Managing Editor at Black and White Trading Ltd based in Kingston upon Hull, UK. He is a prolific author and contributor at Workplace Wellbeing Professional, with over 127 published posts covering HR, employee engagement, and workplace wellbeing topics. His writing focuses on contemporary employment issues including pension schemes, employee health, financial struggles affecting workers, and broader workplace trends.

Latest news

NHS badge review raises wider questions about political expression at work

A government-backed NHS review has reignited debate over political symbols at work and how employers can balance protected beliefs with workplace conduct.

Andrew Fettes-Brown: Leading with curiosity – why the built environment needs a culture shift to allow for innovation

Curiosity creates the conditions for learning, growth and understanding. It encourages us to interrogate problems properly rather than rushing to solutions.

Mental health ‘stigma’ still stops staff speaking to managers

Most employees remain uncomfortable discussing mental health concerns with managers despite growing workplace wellbeing investment.

UK set for biggest rise in unemployment among G7 nations, OECD warns

Britain is forecast to record the largest rise in unemployment among G7 economies this year as economic growth slows and labour market conditions weaken.
- Advertisement -

UK employers ‘risk falling behind global rivals on AI hiring’

UK employers remain cautious about artificial intelligence in recruitment while overseas rivals move faster to adopt AI hiring tools.

Carly Jenner of Apeel Sciences

A global people leader shares how list-making, wellness routines and international teamwork shape her working day in HR.

Must read

Group Risk – A good annual report … but still work to do?

The group risk market, providing group life, group income protection and group critical illness is a real success story, covering more people than ever before as employers seek truly valuable differentiators in the war for talent.

Joanna Hunt: Is the Tier 2 system in crisis?

It has not been the best of years so far for the Home Office. Immigration stories have dominated the front pages and claimed the career of at least one cabinet secretary. The department is under significant pressure to get ready for Brexit whilst still reeling from the fall out from the Windrush saga.
- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you