HRreview Header

Ania Krasniewska on Human Quotas

-

“This kind of change will be legislation driven.”

Context

At a recent HR event in London, one theme dominated discussion: the idea of “human quotas” — legal requirements for minimum levels of human involvement in work as artificial intelligence transforms production and decision-making.

Ania Krasniewska, group vice president at research and advisory firm Gartner, said that while many workplace revolutions have been led by corporate strategy, this one will come from above. “This kind of change won’t be organizationally driven; it will be legislation driven,” she said in an interview with news site Business Insider at the Gartner HR Symposium.

Analysts at advisory firm Gartner predicted that by 2032, at least 30 percent of the world’s top economies will introduce certified human quotas. These measures would ensure that people remain meaningfully involved in creative and operational processes even as AI systems take on more of the workload.

Meaning

Krasniewska’s comments reflect a growing recognition that, without regulatory boundaries, automation could marginalise human workers across sectors. The concept of “human in the loop” — requiring people to oversee and correct AI decisions — is already embedded in the European Union’s AI Act, which mandates human oversight for high-risk systems.

She pointed to a recent Australian High Court ruling as a possible precedent. The court found that employers must consider redeploying staff before outsourcing or restructuring, a principle that could extend to how businesses balance AI and human work in future.

Implications

If governments adopt human quotas, HR departments will need robust systems to document where and how human oversight occurs. Krasniewska said businesses may have to “prove they’re doing it”, requiring new audit trails, disclosures and reporting standards.

Such regulation could increase compliance costs for firms but also reinforce the value of human judgment, especially in areas like healthcare, law and data management, where accountability is critical.

It may represent a safeguard for employees, against full automation, ensuring that human skill and intuition remain embedded in decision-making processes.

As AI integration accelerates, Krasniewska’s warning is that future workforce policy will not be left to corporate goodwill. It will be written into law.

Latest news

Turning Workforce Data into Real Insight: A practical session for HR leaders

HR teams are being asked to deliver greater impact with fewer resources. This practical session is designed to help you move beyond instinct and start using workforce data to make faster, smarter decisions that drive real business results.

Bethany Cann of Specsavers

A working day balancing early talent strategy, university partnerships and family life at the international opticians retailer.

Workplace silence leaving staff afraid to raise mistakes

Almost half of UK workers feel unable to raise concerns or mistakes at work, with new research warning that workplace silence is damaging productivity.

Managers’ biggest fears? ‘Confrontation and redundancies’

Survey of UK managers reveals fear of confrontation and redundancies, with many lacking training to handle difficult workplace situations.
- Advertisement -

Mike Bond: Redefining talent – and prioritising the creative mindset

Not too long ago, the most prized CVs boasted MBAs, consulting pedigrees and an impressive record of traditional experience. Now, things are different.

UK loses ground in global remote work rankings

Connectivity gaps across the UK risk weakening the country’s appeal to remote workers and internationally mobile talent.

Must read

Gary Cattermole: Personality trait mapping and employee engagement

Gary Cattermole, Director of The Survey Initiative, discusses how regional differences and stereotypes can affect staff at work and how organisations can work with different personality types to get the best out of their workforce.

Nick Campbell: Why up-to-date workplace training is more important than ever

"Following a recent Employee Appeal Tribunal (EAT) case, there is now legal precedent that up-to-date and meaningful training is not just important, but a necessity."
- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you