HRreview Header

Tribunal upholds dismissal of remote employee who falsified timesheets

-

- Advertisment -

Sharon Wiltshire, formerly a senior finance co-ordinator at Bath Spa University Students’ Union, was dismissed for gross misconduct following an internal investigation into her timesheet records.

Wiltshire, who joined the union in April 2017, was responsible for the day-to-day financial tasks of the organisation. Discrepancies between her timesheets and IT log-in records came to light during a period of performance concerns and internal review. Her dismissal was upheld by the tribunal, which concluded the organisation had a genuine reason to believe she had falsified records.

Employment Judge Manjit Hallen ruled that the decision to dismiss Wiltshire fell within the band of reasonable responses, adding that her explanations for the discrepancies were unconvincing. The tribunal found that her conduct undermined the essential relationship of trust and confidence required between employer and employee.

Discrepancies limited to remote work periods

Concerns about Wiltshire’s work began in 2023 following changes to the finance department’s software, which she reportedly found difficult. Issues around performance and behaviour led to her being asked to log tasks and their duration. However, she later refused to comply with this request.

An internal investigation led by Head of Finance Gail Boulton identified discrepancies in 53 hours of logged time during an 11-week period. These irregularities were found only during periods when Wiltshire worked remotely. When working from the office, her timesheets and system login records matched closely.

The review revealed several instances where Wiltshire recorded earlier start times and later end times than the system showed. On other occasions, she claimed to be working remotely at hours when no activity was logged. She also submitted timesheets indicating she was working outside standard hours, with no supporting evidence.

Dismissal deemed reasonable under disciplinary policy

Following the findings, Wiltshire was suspended on full pay and attended a disciplinary hearing. During this process, she offered several explanations for the discrepancies, at one point suggesting her timesheets may have been altered. The disciplinary panel rejected these claims, finding her responsible for falsifying records.

She was dismissed on 29 February for gross misconduct under the union’s disciplinary policy, which lists deliberate falsification of records as grounds for dismissal. Wiltshire later brought a claim for unfair dismissal, which has now been rejected.

Judge Hallen concluded that the employer acted reasonably. “It is more likely that [Ms Wiltshire] was not working at all times when at home especially in the morning when she said she was working,” the judgment stated.

The judge added that the misconduct struck at the core of the employment relationship. “Falsification is dishonest in nature and strikes at the heart of the relationship of trust and confidence,” Hallen said.

Latest news

Peers reject ‘day one’ unfair dismissal rights in Employment Rights Bill vote

Proposals to give new employees the right to claim unfair dismissal from their first day of work have been rejected in the House of Lords.

UK labour market weakens as unemployment rises and vacancies fall

The UK labour market is continuing to soften, with new data from the Office for National Statistics showing a rise in unemployment and a slowdown in pay growth.

Eduardo García Garzón: AI should enhance the human touch – not replace it

With over half of UK businesses investing in AI-powered HR, how can employees trust HR with sensitive issues if they’re only able to interact with bots?

FCA faces industrial action threat over hybrid working changes

Staff at the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) have warned of industrial action if proposals to increase office attendance requirements are implemented.
- Advertisement -

High workplace friction impacting productivity in UK, study suggests

An alarming 93 percent of UK workers are experiencing friction in the workplace - with drawbacks "significantly" affecting performance and productivity.

Elizabeth Hardwick-Smith of Pick Everard

Pick Everard’s Group People & Culture Director on purposeful leadership, career pivots and why HR must help drive sustainability.

Must read

Simon Daly: Rethinking workplace success for future generations – building an environment of engagement over happiness 

When it comes to workplace fulfilment, it’s common to discuss employee happiness and engagement as one and the same. Yet the two states are different.

Iain Chadwick: 24 months later…How auto-enrolment shapes the workplace pension revolution

Two years since the first companies reached their staging dates, auto-enrolment continues to throw up a lot of new challenges to HR and pensions professionals.
- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you