Sacked doctor claims unfair dismissal at Tribunal

-

tribunalA heart specialist sacked by a Hospital Trust in 2010 has told an employment tribunal that he was dismissed after a “witch hunt” was carried out against him.

Dr Raj Mattu was fired by University Hospital of Coventry and Warwickshire NHS Trust in 2010, but the case relates back to incidents that commenced in 2001.

In 2001, he “went public” with his experiences of overcrowding in NHS hospitals, publishing details of an experience he had in 1999 where he claimed that five patients had been allocated to four bed-bays in an NHS hospital, leading to hospital staff being unable to use vital equipment to save the life of a patient.

A review in 2004 however cleared the NHS Hospital Trust of any wrongdoing relating to the overcrowding.

HRreview Logo

Get our essential weekday HR news and updates.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Keep up with the latest in HR...
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
Optin_date
This field is hidden when viewing the form

 

In February 2002, Dr Raj Mattu was suspended by the University Hospital of Coventry and Warwickshire NHS Trust on allegations that he had been bullying and harassing other staff members; however he was cleared of these allegations in July 2007 and returned to work, only to be dismissed again in 2010.

Dr Mattu told the Birmingham Employment Tribunal that he believed the Trust had instructed the Head of Security at the hospital to spy on him in order to gain information on potential misconduct or incompetence.

The Court then heard from Dr Mattu that he believed the reason he was dismissed was because he had blown the whistle in 2001. He added that the Trust’s “unlawful actions” had damaged his health, professional reputation and his livelihood.

He is claiming unfair dismissal, and racial and disability discrimination, all of which the Trust denies.

In response to the claims, the Hospital Trust stated that the reason for Dr Mattu’s dismissal was down to his poor relationship with other hospital staff, claiming that more than 40 colleagues at the hospital in Coventry had fallen out with him prior to his dismissal.

The Tribunal is expected to last until August.

Latest news

Helen Wada: Why engagement initiatives fail without human-centric leadership

Workforce engagement has become a hot topic across the boardroom and beyond, particularly as hybrid working practices have become the norm.

Recruiters warned to move beyond ‘post and pray’ as passive talent overlooked

Employers risk missing most candidates by relying on job boards as hiring methods struggle to deliver quality applicants.

Employment tribunal roundup: Appeal fairness, dismissal reasoning, discrimination tests and religious belief clarified

Decisions examine appeal failures, dismissal reasoning, discrimination claims and religious belief, offering practical guidance on fairness, causation and proportionality.

Fears of AI cheating in hiring ‘overblown’ as employers urged to rethink assessments

Employers may be overstating concerns about AI misuse in recruitment as evidence of candidate manipulation remains limited.
- Advertisement -

More employees use workplace health benefits, but barriers still limit access

Many workers struggle to access employer healthcare support due to confusion, costs and unclear processes.

Gender pay gap in tech widens to nine-year high as AI roles drive salaries

Women in IT earn less as salaries rise faster in male-dominated AI and cybersecurity roles, widening pay differences.

Must read

Dave Chaplin: How to take reasonable care when hiring contractors under the new IR35 rules

"If a hiring firm is seen to be evaluating its contractors on a case-by-case basis, it will stand out in a shrinking market to the best and brightest talent."

Dr. Poornima Luthra: What HR leaders should, and shouldn’t, say in moments of societal crisis

Times of social tension offer an opportunity for learning and growth, for fostering truly inclusive workplaces, if approached intentionally.
- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you