Home Blog

Frank Jaquez: Hiring for similarity won’t build the workforce of the future

0

However, the challenge is that culture fit can easily become a measure of familiarity rather than future potential. Instead of assessing what a candidate could contribute, organisations can find themselves favouring people who resemble those already in the business through their career path, communication style or approach to work.

Over time, this can lead to teams that draw on similar experiences and perspectives when making decisions. While that may create alignment, it can also limit an organisation’s ability to challenge assumptions, identify new opportunities and adapt to change.

As organisations face growing pressure to navigate technological disruption, shifting customer expectations and evolving workforce demands, recruitment must become less focused on finding people who fit an existing mould and more focused on identifying those who can strengthen the organisation’s capabilities.

The risk of hiring for familiarity

Most hiring managers are not consciously looking for candidates who think like them, but familiarity can play a powerful role in recruitment decisions. This is where hiring blind spots can emerge. Candidates who communicate, think or solve problems in familiar ways may be viewed more favourably, while those who bring different perspectives or experiences can be overlooked.

Candidates who share similar backgrounds, experiences or ways of communicating often feel like a safer choice. They appear easier to integrate into existing teams and can create an immediate sense of alignment. Yet, when familiarity becomes a deciding factor, organisations risk overlooking individuals who could bring valuable new skills, knowledge or methods to the workforce.

What starts as an effort to maintain a strong culture can gradually become a barrier to fresh thinking. Teams become increasingly likely to tackle challenges in the same way, rely on established ways of thinking and miss opportunities to rethink how work gets done.

The most effective organisations recognise that culture is about creating a shared set of values and behaviours that allow people with different strengths and experiences to work towards common goals. Rather than asking, “How well will this person fit in?”, organisations should increasingly ask, “What will this person add?” Hiring for culture add encourages leaders to focus on the skills, experiences and perspectives that strengthen an existing team rather than replicate what is already there.

The importance of broader thinking

Today’s business environment rewards adaptability. Organisations are increasingly being asked to make decisions in conditions of uncertainty, balancing short-term priorities with long-term transformation.

As organisations navigate ongoing change, success depends on their ability to solve complex challenges, adapt quickly and continuously develop new skills. Achieving this is far more difficult when teams draw on the same perspectives and approaches.

When organisations bring together individuals with different expertise, experiences and ways of thinking, they create stronger foundations for problem-solving and decision-making.  Different perspectives are more likely to challenge assumptions, identify blind spots, and uncover opportunities that may otherwise go unnoticed.

The strongest workplace cultures provide a common framework while encouraging employees to contribute their own strengths, experiences and insights. They create alignment without demanding conformity and foster a sense of belonging without requiring people to think alike or follow the same path to success.

Recruiting for tomorrow, not replacing yesterday

One of the most common hiring mistakes is treating recruitment as a replacement exercise.

When an employee leaves, organisations often look for someone with a similar background, comparable experience and a career path that mirrors the individual they are replacing. Although this may feel like the safest option, it can prevent organisations from building the expertise they will need in the future.

Instead of asking who can do the job exactly as it has always been done, leaders should instead ask: what skills, knowledge and perspectives does the team need next?

This is where skills management becomes increasingly important. With only 11% of employees reporting the use of formal skills assessments and 69% unclear about which skills matter most, many organisations still lack a clear understanding of the skills that exist within their workforce and the gaps they need to address.

Without that visibility, recruitment decisions can become reactive and driven by instinct. With it, organisations can make more strategic hiring decisions that build workforce readiness and support future business goals.

Moving from instinct to evidence

Building stronger teams requires a more structured approach to recruitment.

When organisations clearly define the skills, behaviours and capabilities needed for success, hiring decisions become more objective and consistent. The focus shifts away from whether a candidate feels like the right fit and towards whether they can help the organisation achieve its goals, contribute something new and strengthen the team’s overall capability.

This approach also helps organisations recognise potential in candidates whose experience may not follow traditional expectations. Career changers, individuals returning to the workforce and professionals with non-linear career journeys often bring highly transferable skills and fresh approaches to finding solutions.

For HR leaders, this means embedding greater consistency throughout the hiring process. Structured interviews, skills-based assessments and clearly defined evaluation criteria can help ensure candidates are measured against what matters most. It also means challenging vague feedback such as “they weren’t the right fit” and encouraging discussions grounded in skills, performance and business needs.

Building teams that can evolve

Every hiring decision shapes the future of an organisation. The businesses best positioned for long-term success will be those that treat recruitment as a strategic tool for expanding skills, broadening perspectives and strengthening their ability to navigate uncertainty.

Strong cultures are not built by repeatedly hiring people who think and work in the same way. They are built by creating environments where people can contribute different experiences, perspectives and skills while working towards shared goals. Every hire should be viewed as an opportunity to strengthen a team, challenge assumptions and expand what an organisation is capable of achieving.

The organisations best positioned for the future will be those that look beyond culture fit and focus instead on what individuals can contribute and add to the organisation. HR leaders need to ensure their organisations have the skills, talent and thinking required to succeed in the future.

AI job cuts expected as UK hiring stalls, CIPD warns, but tech firms expand recruitment

0
People walking about in a city,

A growing number of UK employers expect artificial intelligence to reduce their workforce over the next year, with one in four organisations already using the technology anticipating job cuts, up from 21 percent a year ago, according to research from the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD).

The professional body for HR and people development found that 25 percent of employers using AI expect it to reduce headcount over the next 12 months, while only 5 percent anticipate an increase in staffing because of the technology, down from 8 percent last year. Across all employers, 21 percent expect AI-related reductions, although 61 percent believe it will make no difference to workforce numbers.

The figures come as recruitment intentions remain close to historic lows, with just 58 percent of private sector employers planning to hire over the next three months. The CIPD’s autumn Labour Market Outlook shows that employment confidence has remained subdued for seven consecutive quarters, with rising employment costs and economic uncertainty continuing to discourage recruitment.

The picture is different among companies developing AI technology, however. Anthropic, the US company behind the Claude AI assistant, has secured a 158,000 sq ft London office capable of accommodating approximately 800 employees. Its expansion, announced in April, illustrates the growing demand for specialist AI workers at a time when many employers elsewhere in the economy are limiting recruitment.

Employers using AI expect further workforce changes

The CIPD research shows that 83 percent of employers have adopted AI, although much of that activity remains experimental. Two in five organisations use the technology on an ad hoc basis, while 35 percent have integrated it into particular business functions and just 8 percent have embedded it deeply into their operations and strategy.

The extent of AI adoption makes a considerable difference to employers’ expectations about staffing. Among organisations where the technology is deeply integrated, 44 percent anticipate reducing headcount over the next year, compared with 15 percent of those still experimenting with it. However, 17 percent of employers with deeply integrated AI expect it to increase their workforce, more than four times the proportion across all employers.

Larger private sector employers are particularly likely to anticipate reductions, with 33 percent expecting AI to reduce staffing levels. By contrast, only 12 percent of private sector small and medium-sized employers foresee cuts, while 77 percent expect their workforce numbers to remain unchanged.

CIPD chief executive Neil Carberry said employers further ahead in adopting AI were more likely to anticipate changes to jobs because they had a better understanding of how the technology could affect work and skills requirements.

“While the majority of organisations are not currently expecting to reduce headcount because of AI in the next 12 months, those employers who are further ahead on their adoption journey are more likely to report future changes to jobs,” he said in a foreword to the report. “These employers are more likely to expect both job loss and job creation due to having a better understanding of how to adapt work and skills alongside its use.”

Anthropic expands as demand for AI specialists grows

Anthropic’s London expansion provides a contrasting example of the employment opportunities being created by companies developing AI systems. The company has secured new premises at One Triton Square, near Euston, as part of plans to expand its research and commercial operations in Europe. The move follows substantial growth in its London workforce, which numbered more than 200 employees when the expansion was announced.

Anthropic has also made its stock market debut on the Nasdaq exchange, becoming one of the world’s most valuable publicly traded companies with a valuation of approximately $1.76 trillion (£1.3 trillion). Its shares rose around 17 percent on their first day of trading on Thursday, reflecting investor enthusiasm for AI technology despite continuing concerns about the enormous sums being invested in its development.

Its expansion comes amid increasing competition for experienced AI researchers and engineers. The company has advertised highly specialised London engineering positions offering remuneration packages reaching £630,000, reflecting the intense competition for a relatively small pool of advanced AI talent rather than typical salaries in the technology sector.

Other major AI companies have also expanded their London operations. OpenAI, the US developer of ChatGPT, has agreed to take 88,500 sq ft of office space in King’s Cross, while Databricks, an American data and AI software company, has secured 137,000 sq ft in Fitzrovia.

The contrast illustrates how AI can affect employment in different ways. Organisations adopting the technology may reduce the number of employees needed for certain activities, while companies developing increasingly sophisticated AI systems require additional specialist workers.

Recruitment remains close to historic lows

Across the wider economy, employers continue to exercise caution over staffing. The CIPD’s net employment balance, which measures the difference between organisations expecting workforce numbers to increase and those anticipating reductions, stands at +10, compared with +21 in autumn 2024.

Only 26 percent of employers expect to increase staffing levels over the next three months, while 16 percent anticipate reductions and half expect no change. Private sector employment intentions stand at +13, while the public sector has returned to a marginally positive balance of +1 following a prolonged period of weakness.

Recruitment pressures also vary considerably between industries. Care, social work and other healthcare activities have the strongest employment intentions, with a balance of +33, followed by legal, accounting and consultancy services at +26. Information and communication stands at +20, while finance and insurance has a negative balance of -4.

Despite the weakness in recruitment, 30 percent of employers report having vacancies that are difficult to fill. The CIPD said this reflected continuing mismatches between the skills organisations require and those available in the labour market, even as the total number of vacancies has fallen substantially from its 2022 peak.

Pay expectations remain restrained, with employers anticipating a median basic pay increase of 3 percent over the next 12 months. That figure has remained unchanged for 10 consecutive quarters, raising the prospect of further pressure on employees’ living standards if inflation remains above anticipated pay awards.

AI productivity gains bring workforce planning challenges

The CIPD also examined whether employers are seeing improvements in job performance from AI. Among organisations using the technology, 62 percent reported better performance, although most described the improvement as modest. Only 10 percent reported substantial gains, while 28 percent said AI had made no difference.

Employers that have integrated AI more extensively were considerably more positive. Some 35 percent of those with deeply embedded systems reported substantial improvements in job performance, compared with just 4 percent of organisations still experimenting with the technology.

The report argues that changes to headcount alone will not capture AI’s full impact on employment. Recruitment patterns, job responsibilities and skills requirements may change long before organisations make significant adjustments to workforce numbers, making job redesign and employee development increasingly important.

Carberry called for conditions that would encourage organisations to invest in skills and use AI productively, rather than focusing solely on reducing costs.

“Optimising the benefits of AI will require a stable and supportive policy and business environment which can underpin skills investment and maximise employment growth as the technology changes tasks and jobs, and aid organisations in using AI safely and productively,” he said.

The challenge for HR departments is to anticipate which roles and skills will change, identify opportunities to retrain existing employees and ensure that productivity improvements can support growth rather than simply reducing staffing requirements.

The CIPD’s autumn Labour Market Outlook is based on a representative survey of 2,051 UK employers. It examines recruitment, redundancy and pay intentions alongside AI adoption, offering a picture of a labour market in which hiring remains subdued even as the technology creates new demands for specialist skills.

McDonald’s loses bid to block 450 discrimination claims by young workers

0
McDonald's french fries.

Hundreds of current and former McDonald’s employees will be able to pursue discrimination claims against the fast-food chain after an employment tribunal judge rejected its attempt to have the cases struck out, allowing allegations concerning the treatment of young and female workers to proceed to a full hearing.

Employment Judge Glennie ruled on Monday that more than 450 complaints could proceed following a two-day hearing earlier this month. The claims, brought by law firm Leigh Day, concern alleged indirect age and sex discrimination involving employees who were aged between 16 and 19 when working at McDonald’s restaurants across England, Wales and Scotland.

The claimants allege that systemic failures left younger employees and women exposed to harassment, discrimination and unsafe working conditions. They are seeking to establish whether McDonald’s and its franchisees bear legal responsibility for the alleged failures. The company denies the claims, which are expected to be heard in April 2027.

The ruling follows years of scrutiny of working conditions at the restaurant chain, including a BBC investigation in 2023 that uncovered allegations of widespread sexual harassment involving employees, some as young as 17. Further allegations emerged in subsequent reporting, raising concerns about the protection of younger workers and the effectiveness of measures introduced by the company.

Former employee describes harassment concerns

A former McDonald’s employee told the BBC that managers failed to protect younger staff from inappropriate behaviour, including sexualised comments from customers and older colleagues.

Hope, now 22, worked at a restaurant in the West Midlands in 2023. She described an environment in which older employees discussed waiting for teenage colleagues to turn 18 before pursuing sexual relationships with them.

She also alleged that a manager dismissed her concerns after two customers subjected her to sexualised behaviour during a night shift. According to her account, she was told to tolerate the situation rather than receiving support.

Hope said her motivation for joining the legal action was to improve the treatment of younger employees rather than obtain financial compensation. She expressed particular concern about teenagers entering their first jobs without sufficient protection from inappropriate behaviour.

The BBC understands that the claims allowed to proceed concern indirect discrimination rather than standalone sexual harassment complaints. The allegations of harassment nevertheless form part of the wider circumstances underlying the legal action.

Tribunal rejects attempt to dismiss claims

Leigh Day launched the proceedings in autumn 2023, arguing that McDonald’s had failed to take appropriate steps to safeguard younger workers. The firm contends that the case will test the extent to which the parent company can be held responsible for employment practices across its franchised restaurants.

Kiran Daurka, a partner at Leigh Day, criticised the company’s attempts to prevent the claims reaching a full hearing, particularly given the previous allegations and its engagement with the Equality and Human Rights Commission, Britain’s equality watchdog.

“McDonald’s took a very serious and draconian step in applying to strike out our clients’ claims in their entirety,” she said. “However, the tribunal has recognised that it would have been unjust to do so in this case.”

She added the the firm’s “clients were children or adolescents when they worked at McDonald’s, and our clients have been very brave in standing up collectively to this huge corporation to raise what they allege to be failures in working systems and practices”.

The decision allows the allegations to be examined at a full hearing but does not establish that McDonald’s or its franchisees acted unlawfully.

McDonald’s said maintaining a safe and respectful working environment remained a fundamental priority. The company said it had introduced extensive safeguarding measures and continued working with external experts to improve workplace protections.

“Any form of harassment, discrimination or inappropriate behaviour is unacceptable and has no place in our restaurants or offices,” a spokesperson said. “We are confident that with the guidance and partnership of external experts, we and our franchisees have industry leading safeguarding measures in place.”

Employers warned over harassment by customers

The case also brings attention to employers’ responsibilities when inappropriate behaviour comes from customers rather than colleagues, particularly in hospitality, retail and other customer-facing workplaces.

Matthew Potter, an employment partner at law firm Howes Percival, told HRreview that employers must take preventative action against sexual harassment and respond effectively when employees report incidents. He pointed to changes introduced under the Employment Rights Act 2025, which strengthened obligations concerning workplace sexual harassment.

“The allegations against McDonald’s highlight the importance of employers taking proactive steps to protect staff from sexual harassment, including inappropriate behaviour by customers,” he said. “This is particularly significant following changes introduced by the Employment Rights Act 2025, which came into force on 30 October 2026 and strengthened employers’ obligations to take all reasonable steps to prevent sexual harassment, extending liability for harassment by third parties.”

Potter said managers should investigate complaints promptly and consider practical safeguards, including removing employees from contact with customers responsible for inappropriate conduct or banning those individuals from the premises.

The legal distinction remains important: the McDonald’s proceedings concern alleged indirect discrimination, while Potter’s comments address the broader duties employers face in preventing sexual harassment, including conduct by third parties.

Younger employees need additional safeguards

Potter warned that employees aged 16 and 17 may face particular difficulties reporting inappropriate conduct because they have limited workplace experience and may be reluctant to challenge managers, colleagues or customers.

“Younger workers, particularly those aged 16 and 17 may be especially vulnerable due to their limited workplace experience and reluctance to challenge inappropriate behaviour. Employers should recognise these risks and consider additional safeguards, including age-appropriate training, clear reporting procedures and enhanced manager supervision.”

The challenge for HR departments is to ensure that safeguarding policies work in practice, particularly where employees are young, inexperienced or dependent on managers to intervene when customers behave inappropriately. Clear reporting arrangements, appropriate training and prompt investigations are important, alongside ensuring that complaints can be raised without fear of adverse consequences.

Potter said businesses in customer-facing sectors should examine their existing arrangements to ensure that preventative measures are effective and that managers understand their responsibilities.

“For businesses operating in the retail, hospitality and food-service sectors, this serves as an important reminder that customer behaviour is an employer’s responsibility too and that they can be liable for harassment of their staff by third parties,” he said. “Employers should review their harassment policies, workplace risk assessments, reporting mechanisms and management training to ensure preventative measures are in place.”

The McDonald’s claims are expected to return to the employment tribunal in April 2027, when the allegations and questions of legal responsibility will be considered in full.

Microsoft outage prompts warnings over employee communication and workplace disruption

0
A close-up of a screen displaying Microsoft products.

Employers have been urged to prepare staff for the failure of workplace communication systems after a global Microsoft outage disrupted email, messaging and other essential services, leaving employees unable to carry out normal duties and potentially exposing organisations to security and compliance risks.

The disruption, which began on Thursday last week and continued into the following day, affected Microsoft Outlook, Teams and other Microsoft 365 services used by businesses, government departments and public services worldwide. Employees faced problems sending emails, arranging meetings and communicating with colleagues, while organisations dependent on several interconnected Microsoft products found that their usual alternatives could also be unavailable.

Microsoft subsequently confirmed that the outage was caused by a technical fault rather than a cyberattack or artificial intelligence. A bug introduced during an earlier network capacity upgrade was triggered by a more recent network change, causing cascading failures across its infrastructure. The company gradually restored services, with the remaining affected customers and regions brought back online by Saturday.

The mayhem has prompted warnings that employers need more than technical recovery arrangements to maintain operations. Staff must know how to contact colleagues and managers, which alternative communication channels are permitted and where to find emergency procedures when their usual workplace systems cannot be accessed.

Employees need clear alternatives when systems fail

Roy Shelton, chief executive of Glu Digital Group, a digital technology and services company, said the outage demonstrated why employers should prepare for disruption regardless of whether it results from malicious activity or a technical failure.

“Whenever a major service such as Microsoft 365 goes down, the immediate reaction is often to question whether we’re dealing with a cyberattack. It’s understandable, particularly given the current threat landscape, but it’s important not to jump to conclusions. A significant outage doesn’t automatically mean malicious activity.

“What this incident demonstrates is that businesses need to prepare for disruption regardless of its cause. Whether it’s a cyberattack, a network configuration issue or a technical failure, the impact on employees, customers and business operations can be just as serious.”

The simultaneous loss of Outlook and Teams illustrates the difficulties facing organisations that use interconnected services for both routine communication and emergency coordination. Employees may be unable to contact managers, receive instructions or report urgent problems, particularly if telephone numbers and recovery procedures are stored within the affected systems.

Shelton urged organisations to test how their employees would respond if their normal communication channels disappeared, rather than assuming that written contingency plans would be sufficient. Managers also need to know who has responsibility for declaring an incident and how staff, customers and suppliers will be contacted while services remain unavailable.

“Ask yourself what would happen if Outlook and Teams were both unavailable for the next hour. Who would declare an incident? How would you contact employees, customers and suppliers? Could your service desk still receive urgent calls?

“Your emergency contact lists and recovery procedures must be accessible outside the systems you’re trying to recover. Otherwise, you risk discovering that your continuity plan is just as unavailable as the technology itself.”

Unapproved messaging creates compliance risks

The outage also exposed a potential problem for employers when staff turn to personal communication tools to keep working. Employees who cannot access approved systems may use WhatsApp, text messages or personal email accounts, potentially moving sensitive information outside established security and record-keeping arrangements.

Shaun Hurst, principal regulatory adviser at Smarsh, a company providing communications compliance and archiving technology, warned that the consequences could be particularly serious in regulated industries, where organisations are required to retain records of certain business communications.

“When email isn’t working and a client needs an answer, people find other ways to communicate. WhatsApp, text messages, personal email. It’s understandable, but if those communications aren’t being captured, you’ve potentially created a compliance problem while trying to work around an IT problem. Regulatory obligations don’t disappear because a technology provider is having a bad day. In the EU, the Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA) has only increased the scrutiny around concentration risk and operational resilience, and the UK’s own rules are moving the same way.”

The problem is not limited to employees choosing unapproved applications. Hurst said some of the systems used to supervise communications and retrieve records could become unavailable alongside the platforms they monitor, leaving compliance teams unable to access information during an incident.

He called for employers to test whether staff understand which alternative channels they can use and whether communications made through those channels can still be recorded and retrieved. Such arrangements need to work during an actual disruption, rather than existing only in written policies.

“The outage also showed that some of the tools firms rely on to supervise communications and retrieve records can go down with the platform itself. Firms need to test what happens when their approved business communications platforms go down. They should confirm that staff know which channels they can switch to, that communications on those channels are captured, and that compliance teams can still access the records they need during the outage. That needs testing, not just documenting.”

Shelton also warned that employees would find ways to continue working when their usual systems failed, even if employers had not established approved alternatives. Providing clear instructions and secure communication options would therefore be important in preventing staff from inadvertently creating additional risks during an outage.

Reliance on major providers leaves workplaces exposed

Professor Raj Rajarajan, director of the Institute for Cyber Security at City St George’s, University of London, said the disruption demonstrated the wider consequences of organisations depending heavily on a small number of technology suppliers.

“This Microsoft outage remains a powerful illustration of the risks of relying on a small number of technology providers and the significant economic consequences of large-scale service disruptions.”

Rajarajan, who also co-founded Cyber London, an initiative supporting the capital’s cybersecurity sector, argued that organisations needed more resilient infrastructure and greater diversity among their technology providers. He recommended systems capable of switching between suppliers when essential services became unavailable, reducing the likelihood that a failure at one provider would interrupt multiple business functions.

He also warned that growing demand for AI services could create further challenges for digital infrastructure over the next 12 to 15 months. Although Microsoft has ruled out AI as the cause of this outage, Rajarajan said the increasing integration of AI into essential services would place additional demands on computing capacity and create new cybersecurity risks.

“To strengthen resilience, we must invest in sovereign hardware and software capabilities while avoiding excessive reliance on any single vendor or technology ecosystem. A diverse, multi-vendor strategy can help reduce systemic risks and improve operational continuity during outages or disruptions.”

The incident also prompted a government response. In a statement to Parliament on 16 November, Ian Murray, the minister for creative industries, media and online safety, confirmed that UK employees had been unable to perform normal duties and that businesses had experienced difficulties completing transactions. Public services were also affected, although essential services including emergency calls remained operational.

Murray said the government expected Microsoft to explain the lessons learned from the incident and how it intended to prevent similar disruption. Officials were continuing to assess the wider effects on businesses and public services.

Preparing managers and staff for disruption

The warnings have implications for how organisations prepare their workforces, particularly where employees rely on digital platforms for instructions, collaboration and access to essential information. Technical recovery remains important, but staff also need practical guidance on what to do while systems are unavailable.

HR teams and line managers may have a role in ensuring that employees know where to find emergency contact details, who will communicate instructions during an outage and which alternative applications can be used safely. These arrangements are particularly important for remote and hybrid workers who may not have an immediate way to contact colleagues when workplace messaging systems fail.

Employers also need to consider whether their procedures have been tested with staff. An alternative communication channel is of limited value if employees do not know it exists, cannot access it or are uncertain whether they are authorised to use it.

As Shelton observed, maintaining continuity depends as much on preparing employees as it does on restoring technology.

“Business continuity isn’t simply about having backup technology. It’s about giving people clear instructions, safe alternatives and the confidence to keep operating when the unexpected happens.”

Balancing business growth with fairness and opportunity at work

0
Ruby Kite

Ruby Kite knows that building a successful business involves more than recruiting talented people. As vice-president of people at The PHA Group, an independent creative communications agency, she oversees HR across its UK operations and expanding US business, where differing employment laws, workplace expectations and commercial pressures all demand careful attention. Having joined the agency more than seven years ago, she has progressed from internal recruitment and inclusion initiatives to leading its entire People function.

The 32-year-old lives in Hertfordshire with her husband and their nearly two-year-old son, while her working life centres on Covent Garden in London. Her career began at a specialist public relations recruitment agency before she moved to PHA, then her favourite client. Now advising the chief executive and senior leadership team, she has recently overhauled performance and reward frameworks, career pathways and HR systems, while helping the agency manage international growth.

For Kite, good HR is as much about challenging commercial decisions as supporting employees. She considers why traditional approaches to promotion can disadvantage talented specialists, how employers can tackle the working conditions behind burnout and what AI could mean for junior employees in creative industries. She also examines the practical implications of employment law reform and why HR needs to be involved in business decisions before problems arise.

The PHA Group has expanded into the US, adding to its UK operations. What have been the biggest people challenges in supporting international growth, particularly when employment practices and workplace expectations differ between countries?

One of the biggest challenges for a business expanding from the UK has been navigating how employment rights and benefits vary across US states and sometimes even between cities. We also have two separate US entities, adding another layer to decisions about payroll, benefits and policies, which means each hire or relocation needs careful consideration.

In the UK, we’ve had years to develop our policies and processes as legislation and the business have evolved. Building a similarly dependable foundation across the US has meant learning quickly, working closely with local providers and knowing where specialist advice is needed. Time differences of up to eight hours also make planning and communication particularly important.

That work has made us more deliberate about what employees should experience consistently across the business and where arrangements need to reflect local requirements and expectations. Our people need to understand how to access support, what’s expected of them and how they can develop, wherever they’re based. 

For me, the reward is seeing that groundwork support closer collaboration between UK and US colleagues. Reliable processes make it easier to support each new employee and help teams work together as the business grows.

How do you balance the commercial demands of a fast-paced communications agency with employees’ expectations around workload, flexibility and work-life balance?

I think the balance starts with what we agree to deliver to our clients. If we consistently promise more than a team can reasonably achieve, the pressure will eventually show up in their working hours and quality of work. There’ll always be urgent requests, last-minute pitches and crises, but we’re responsible for deciding how we respond and what needs to change elsewhere.

To support this, managers need to resource accounts accordingly and make decisions when priorities compete. Employees also have a responsibility to manage their time and flag concerns early. Timesheets can be helpful for both parties to identify where pressure is recurring, with accurate records depending on employees seeing that the information leads to action.

My role in this is to give employees regular opportunities to raise any issues and support them in finding a way forward with their manager. It’s also to make sure our policies and benefits support flexibility and work-life balance, and that people feel able to use them. Low uptake can be a warning sign that something isn’t working in practice, whether that’s workload, awareness or concern about how using a benefit might be perceived.

At 32, you’ve already reached a senior HR leadership position. Have you encountered assumptions about age and experience, and what advice would you give younger HR professionals aspiring to executive roles?

Age hasn’t been a barrier I’ve personally encountered. I’ve been at PHA for over seven years and benefited greatly from managers who shared their knowledge of the business, including decisions and experiences that predated me. Working across talent, culture, inclusion and People in that time has also given me different perspectives on how the agency operates in practice, helping me recognise what we can build on and where we need to improve.

My advice to HR professionals earlier in their career would be to get close to the work your colleagues do. HR can be a solitary role, particularly when you’re balancing several issues simultaneously and you are the only constant. Getting under the skin of people’s responsibilities, how teams depend on each other and the challenges they face at each level makes your advice more relevant. It also gives you the confidence to challenge decisions and offer practical alternatives because you understand how they’ll affect people’s day-to-day work.

I’d also encourage younger professionals to practise making recommendations before they feel completely ready by explaining what you’d do, why you’d do it and what trade-offs it would involve. It’s also important to be open about where you need to seek specialist advice or a second perspective. You build trust both by showing how you’ve reached a view and that you’re willing to reconsider it; habits you can develop long before you have a senior title.

PHA has introduced transparent career pathways and structured promotion processes. How do you ensure performance and promotion decisions are genuinely fair, particularly when managers may have very different ideas about what good performance looks like?

If managers have fundamentally different ideas about good performance, I’d question how clearly the business has communicated its expectations. Employees shouldn’t have to work out which version of success applies to them based on who manages them. They should have an understanding of what the business is trying to achieve, how their contribution fits with the broader vision and which behaviours are expected or unacceptable.

Meanwhile, the employee value proposition needs to show up in what leaders recognise, reward and challenge. If we say we value collaboration but consistently reward individual results regardless of how they’re achieved, employees will notice and question whether it’s a business they want to be a part of.

A year ago, we undertook a sizeable project to ensure job descriptions and career pathways translate those expectations into responsibilities at each level. This included consolidating job titles where the distinction between roles was difficult to justify. We also moved to a bi-annual performance cycle, with our April and October reviews giving us a consistent opportunity to consider employees across teams, including those less likely to push for a promotion or pay rise. Reviewing leadership’s recommendations together lets us challenge differences in managers’ assessments.

We take a similarly structured approach to pay, drawing on the Living Wage Foundation’s annual announcement, salary surveys conducted by specialist recruiters and advertised roles to conduct a bi-annual benchmarking exercise. 

Is the traditional annual performance appraisal becoming outdated, and what would a more effective approach to managing performance look like?

I don’t think the annual appraisal is outdated, but rather that its value depends on everything that happens around it. Employees need clear expectations, access to progression opportunities and a manager who gives useful feedback throughout the year. If those foundations are weak, adding more appraisal meetings can become a business’s way of compensating for them.

When I joined PHA, quarterly appraisals had recently been introduced because performance conversations were happening too infrequently. While they were useful in facilitating more regular performance discussions with managers, over time they became a box-ticking exercise and started to revolve largely around the timing of the next promotion. This resulted in objectives becoming narrower and more immediate, with less connection to the agency’s wider priorities.

We’ve since returned to an annual appraisal, enabling a longer view of performance and development, supported by quarterly check-ins that help employees track progress against their objectives, address challenges and feel supported. We find five prompts helpful in the quarterly conversations. Connect asks how someone is feeling about work. Celebrate highlights what’s going well. Challenge explores what’s getting in the way. Champion focuses on how their manager can support them. Commit sets out what each person has agreed to do next.

As the Employment Rights Act brings changes to workplace protections, which reforms do you think will have the greatest practical impact on employers, and where do you foresee the biggest implementation challenges?

I expect the unfair dismissal reforms taking effect on January 1st 2027 to have the greatest practical impact. As a result of the qualifying period for ordinary unfair dismissal falling from two years to six months and the cap on compensatory awards being removed, employers will need to look closely at how they manage hiring, onboarding and probation processes. Will we see as many ambitious growth roles, where businesses hire ahead of demand to support future expansion? Or extended probations beyond six months for those who need more time and support? I suspect not.

Another potential challenge is that much of the implementation will depend on line managers. HR can’t be present for every conversation, email or decision, yet those interactions can become important evidence in a dispute. Employers will need to provide practical training, arrange regular check-ins and make clear when managers should involve HR before concerns escalate.

I’m also concerned about the combined impact of employment reforms and rising minimum wage rates on entry-level opportunities. While it’s vital that salaries reflect the cost of living, businesses need to fund those increases alongside the time spent training new starters with no experience. With limited budgets and management capacity, paying slightly more for a second jobber may become a more attractive option, so HR teams and business leaders will need to spend time considering how they can meet stronger employment standards while continuing to give school leavers and graduates their first opportunity.

Creative agencies depend on fresh ideas and original thinking, yet AI is capable of producing content in seconds. How should HR respond to concerns about job security, changing skills and the potential loss of creative opportunities for junior employees?

I think we need to be honest that AI will inevitably change the shape of most industries. In response, HR teams should help leaders understand what that means for the skills required, while helping employees understand what could change in their roles and how they can prepare for it.

For businesses committed to developing junior talent, there’s an opportunity to use the time AI saves deliberately. If research and first drafts take less time, junior colleagues could get earlier exposure to strategic planning, client conversations and new business pitches, supported by coaching and meaningful responsibility to build those capabilities.

We still need people who can recognise a strong idea, challenge a weak one and understand why something will resonate with an audience. That judgement develops through hands-on experience, so we need to preserve opportunities to build it at every level. Otherwise, we risk creating a workforce of human AI agents passing on outputs they haven’t learned to question.

What do you think employers most frequently misunderstand about retaining talented people, particularly those who are ambitious but may not want to move into management?

I think employers too often treat management as the natural reward for being good at a job. Giving excellent practitioners that significant, often time-consuming, responsibility without the interest or support to succeed can eventually cost you both the person and members of their team.

I appreciate the structural challenge, particularly in agencies. You need people to manage teams and take on greater commercial responsibility, as well as a consistent career framework to help everyone understand how progression works in the context of your business. But there needs to be enough flexibility to recognise where people contribute most by asking what they want from their career and being clear about how their expertise, influence and pay could develop accordingly. A role that gives someone meaningful scope to use their strengths makes staying more compelling and finding something comparable elsewhere more difficult.

It also makes workforce planning more honest. Once you understand what your existing team can and wants to do, you can identify the management, commercial or generalist skills you need to hire. Otherwise, assuming everyone will develop equally via a rigid career pathway can leave you with gaps that only become obvious when someone is struggling in a role they never wanted.

PHA offers enhanced parental benefits, including up to 26 weeks of full maternity and adoption pay. What more should employers be doing to prevent parenthood and caring responsibilities from becoming barriers to career progression?

Enhanced parental pay can make a real difference during periods of parental leave, but preventing parenthood from becoming a career barrier means looking at what happens before leave and after someone returns. Support might start with fertility treatment, pregnancy loss or health conditions people are managing while considering a family. Equally, returning from parental leave shouldn’t mean having to prove your ambition again, particularly when the financial responsibilities of parenthood can make career progression even more important.

Flexibility is an obvious starting point, but how the role is adapted determines whether it works. If someone reduces their hours, which responsibilities change, how are performance expectations adjusted and how is anyone taking on the additional work supported and recognised? Offering flexibility achieves little if someone ends up doing the same work for less pay or finds the arrangement held against them when promotion is discussed.

Support also needs to extend beyond parents to people caring for an elderly parent, a disabled partner or someone else who depends on them. Many won’t identify as carers because they see those responsibilities as simply being part of a family or relationship, so employers need to make clear who can access support, without relying on people to recognise themselves in a policy title, and ensure using it doesn’t limit their career opportunities. This is where clear job descriptions, meaningful appraisals and consistent promotion reviews matter, keeping decisions focused on someone’s contribution rather than assumptions about their availability or ambition.

How comfortable are you challenging the CEO or other senior executives when you believe a commercial decision could have damaging consequences for employees?

I’ve found that senior leaders genuinely want to understand the consequences of their decisions for employees, which makes me feel comfortable in sharing my perspective when needed. We share the objective of making decisions that make commercial sense, and it’s my role to bring the employee perspective into that discussion early enough to influence the approach.

When I need to raise an alternative perspective, I focus on explaining who would be affected, the likely consequences and what we could do differently. Sometimes the decision itself is sound, but the reasoning needs clearer communication. Leaders have often spent weeks discussing something employees are hearing for the first time, so HR can help bridge that gap by anticipating questions, making sure managers understand the rationale and giving employees at all levels a consistent explanation.

Many organisations have invested heavily in employee wellbeing programmes, yet stress and burnout remain persistent problems. Are employers sometimes treating the symptoms rather than addressing the working conditions that cause them?

Yes, in some cases. I also think employers sometimes mistake participation in a wellbeing programme for evidence that people are well. A smaller budget can actually prompt a more useful conversation as when another initiative isn’t an option, there’s more reason to examine what’s causing the pressure and what could change in the working day to reduce it.

Support also needs to keep pace with how people work. Many initiatives introduced during the pandemic addressed isolation, reduced opportunities to exercise and the adjustment to working from home. Those needs haven’t disappeared, but employers should question whether the same offering still fits. That means looking at everyday working conditions alongside individual support. Better resourcing, fewer unnecessary meetings and making sure people can take breaks and annual leave can ease pressure across a team. 

Regardless, HR needs to retain an awareness that two colleagues with similar workloads may be managing very different circumstances. One might benefit from support from an Employee Assistance Programme, while another needs a temporary change to their working pattern. Being fair doesn’t mean offering everyone an identical solution, it means making support accessible, considering requests consistently and checking that an adjustment genuinely helps without leaving someone else with an unsustainable workload.

And finally, how do you see HR evolving over the next five years?

Over the next five years, I think HR’s value will increasingly come from how well we exercise judgement, rather than how much we can manage ourselves. I expect AI to become more embedded in smaller People teams like ours, moving beyond drafting and administration into recommendations about recruitment, performance and workforce planning. Who knows how far that will go. But we’ll need the confidence and knowledge to question it. A pattern in the data doesn’t explain someone’s circumstances, and an apparently objective recommendation can still reinforce bias.

Government decisions about employment law will also shape the future of HR. I expect more of what was considered good practice to become a formal obligation, so People teams will need to become better at anticipating that direction, preparing managers and improving working practices before a deadline forces the issue. For me, progress would mean HR spending less time managing the consequences of decisions it wasn’t involved in and more time helping the business make better ones.

Employment Tribunal Round-up: Rulings on redundancy, disability, whistleblowing and freelance status

0
The Scales of Justice.

A redundancy consultation that failed to meet legal requirements, an employee dismissed over absence reporting and an agency driver denied further work after raising safety concerns are among the disputes considered in four recent Employment Tribunal cases. Another ruling examined whether a supposedly freelance producer was, in fact, an employee entitled to statutory protections.

This month’s round-up, produced in collaboration with employment law platform LexHR, looks at how seemingly routine management decisions can expose organisations to legal claims. The cases involve failures to consult properly, disability discrimination, whistleblowing retaliation and the employment rights of workers engaged on freelance contracts.

The decisions offer lessons for HR professionals on the consequences of getting workplace procedures wrong, particularly when employers rely on established practices or contractual arrangements without examining whether they meet legal requirements. The rulings also show how internal communications, management decisions and the treatment of individual workers can become decisive evidence when disputes reach a tribunal.

Redundancy: consultation and authorised representatives

In Hughes v Accord-UK Ltd and others, the employer consulted an existing employee forum during a redundancy exercise without establishing that its representatives had authority from the affected employees. Individual consultation also gave the claimant materially inaccurate information about where her duties would go, and the appeal failed to address her concerns properly.

The tribunal upheld unfair dismissal and made a 60-day protective award for the collective consultation failure. Total compensation was £23,698.81. Although the tribunal found that a fair process would have led to dismissal after one further month, that did not excuse the consultation failures or eliminate liability.

Key learning points

1. Verify that existing employee representatives have authority to consult on redundancies for the affected workforce; an established forum and its constitution are not sufficient by themselves.

2. Explain accurately how duties will be redistributed and consider employees’ proposals for alternative work; meaningful consultation depends on employees understanding what is actually proposed.

3. Use the appeal to address substantive objections and procedural shortcomings; an eventual redundancy being inevitable does not remove the need for a fair process.

Disability: absence reporting and decisions to dismiss

In Payne v Independent Catering Management Ltd, a catering assistant with anxiety was dismissed following absence and alleged failures to communicate. She had sent messages to a manager, received replies and explained that anxiety affected her ability to handle telephone calls. The tribunal upheld direct disability discrimination in the dismissal and discrimination arising from disability.

The employer’s changing explanation and failure to disclose relevant messages undermined its defence. It had not adequately investigated the circumstances or shown dismissal to be proportionate. Other direct-discrimination allegations failed.

Key learning points

1. Investigate whether disability explains apparent non-compliance with absence procedures, including difficulty making or answering telephone calls, before treating that behaviour as a disciplinary matter.

2. Check all relevant communications and medical information before deciding to dismiss; messages acknowledged by one manager may undermine another manager’s assumption that contact was not maintained.

3. Consider less discriminatory alternatives and record the proportionality assessment; staffing pressures and a legitimate reporting policy do not automatically justify dismissal for disability-related behaviour.

Whistleblowing: withdrawing shifts after safety concerns

In Johnson v Greenlight Recruitment Ltd, an agency driver raised concerns about working hours, breaks and manual handling. The tribunal found that his protected disclosure materially influenced the decision to stop allocating assignments and terminate his engagement. Internal correspondence supported a finding that the agency and another organisation had agreed to maintain an explanation that suitable shifts were unavailable.

Other drivers continued receiving work, and no attempts were made to find him alternative van-driving assignments. His whistleblowing detriment claim succeeded, although his reasonable-adjustments claim failed. This liability judgment left compensation to be determined at a separate remedy hearing.

Key learning points

1. Recognise that withdrawing assignments can constitute a whistleblowing detriment; protection is relevant to workers as well as employees with conventional ongoing employment arrangements.

2. Investigate safety concerns on their merits and document genuine operational reasons for changes to shifts; describing a worker as argumentative can undermine a later explanation.

3. Ensure communications between agencies, clients and other intermediaries reflect the actual decision-making; presenting retaliation as a lack of available work does not protect against liability.

Freelance status: the reality of the working relationship

In Banbury v Culture Squared CIC, a creative producer engaged for the Bradford Literary Festival was described as freelance, an arrangement both parties initially intended. The tribunal nevertheless found that personal service, control and integration into the organisation established employee and worker status. Fixed working expectations, management approval and the similarity to employed producers outweighed contractual labels and tax arrangements.

Negotiating a day rate did not establish that she operated an independent business. Her disability discrimination, victimisation and wages claims could therefore proceed. This was a preliminary determination of status; it did not establish that those substantive claims were well-founded.

Key learning points

1. Assess how freelancers actually work, including supervision, hours, integration and personal service; mutual agreement about self-employment cannot displace the statutory assessment of employment status.

2. Review whether substitution rights and commercial independence exist in practice; restrictions and operational expectations may show that the organisation expects the individual personally to perform the work.

3. Distinguish a status ruling from a decision on liability; employee or worker status opens access to particular protections but does not prove the underlying complaints.

Implications for HR

These decisions emphasise the importance of examining the reality behind workplace arrangements and management explanations. Check representatives’ authority before collective consultation, investigate disability-related behaviour before imposing sanctions, and scrutinise decisions affecting workers who raise concerns. Review freelance arrangements against actual working practices rather than contractual descriptions alone. Clear records and consideration of alternatives help identify weaknesses before disputes arise.

Rodrigo Bolaños: Employers cannot put AI readiness on hold

0

It also raises an uncomfortable dilemma that access to technology that helps someone perform better could depend on their willingness or ability to pay for it themselves.

Calls to slow frontier AI development from tech leaders and governments around the world offer employers little respite from these decisions. Even if developers take more time to strengthen safety, employees still have access to existing models, and their potential to improve work (as well as the risks associated with using them) will still require attention. A pause in development offers no pause in responsibility. Employers have work to do with the technology already in employees’ hands.

Look closely at where the value comes from

There is evidence that AI can help people perform better, although the benefits vary. For instance, a survey of 5,179 customer support agents reported an average productivity increase of 14% from access to an AI assistant. For novice and lower-skilled workers, the increase was 34%.

This is an encouraging example of how AI can help less experienced employees draw on knowledge that might otherwise take years to build. While the results relate to a specific customer support setting, they cannot tell every employer what return to expect, or how much difference training would make. However, they do give HR a reason to look more closely at where people struggle in their work and whether AI could help.

Employees already paying for tools are a useful place to start. Understanding what they find helpful, and why the company’s own software falls short, gives employers something concrete to act on. Employers should be wary of rushing into introducing restrictions without addressing those frustrations, as this could make people less willing to discuss their use, leaving the business with fewer opportunities to learn from it or address issues.

Help people judge what they can trust

An AI answer can sound convincing enough that checking it feels unnecessary. However, employees – especially younger ones – need practice recognising where that confidence is misplaced, using examples that reflect the decisions they face at work.

For a manager summarising information, that might mean checking whether the tool has left out something that would affect a decision. Knowing how to generate a response is only part of doing either job well. For example, a sales professional drafting a customer email needs to consider whether the wording fits the relationship and accurately reflects the customer’s circumstances.

A general introduction to AI can give everyone a starting point. From there, training needs to become more specific, with opportunities to work through familiar tasks and discuss the results. HR should bring IT and security colleagues into that process, so employees understand how the rules apply as they use the tools. Before summarising a document, for example, they need to know whether its contents can safely be shared with these tools.

People also need someone to turn to when they aren’t able to judge an answer for themselves. Managers remain responsible for the resulting work, which means taking an interest in how it was produced and whether the checks were sufficient. Being comfortable using a tool should never be enough to assume someone can use it well.

Look at what changes in the work

After training, managers should look at how people put what they have learned into practice. Are they producing better work, and does it need fewer corrections? Saving an hour on a task means little if a colleague has to spend that hour fixing the result.

Teams also need time to talk through the mistakes they encounter. If someone spots a problem in an AI answer that initially looked convincing, exploring what gave it away can help colleagues avoid the same trap. These discussions give managers a clearer idea of where people still need guidance as they build experience.

But employees need to trust that sharing what they learn will work in their favour. Someone who finds a way to save several hours may keep it to themselves if they think that admission could put their job at risk. Leaders should explain how they intend to use the time AI frees up and give employees a say in what that means for their work.

A global slowdown in AI development would still leave employers with plenty to do. As existing tools are already finding their way into everyday work, sometimes at employees’ own expense, by providing better and more useful support now, organisations stand a better chance of benefiting from the slowdown, while taking responsibility for decisions people are currently making on their own.

Milburn youth jobs plan welcomed but employers warn of hiring costs and red tape

0
A diverse group of young people collaborating in a modern office setting with laptops and plants.

Employers, recruitment organisations and unions have welcomed elements of Alan Milburn’s proposals to tackle youth unemployment but warned that the government’s plans must address hiring costs, employment protections and the quality of jobs available to young people.

The Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD), the professional body for HR and people development, said the former Labour minister had correctly identified the need to give businesses greater confidence to recruit young workers. But it warned that the proposed partnership between employers and the state would fail to deliver unless ministers took responsibility for reducing the barriers to recruitment, rather than leaving businesses to shoulder the risks.

The response follows the publication on Tuesday of Milburn’s independent review, which proposes reducing the proportion of 16- to 24-year-olds not in education, employment or training (NEET) from around 13 percent to 5 percent by 2036. Nearly one million young people are currently in this position, and the report sets out a 10-year programme intended to help hundreds of thousands more enter employment or education.

Prime Minister Andy Burnham endorsed the principles of the review and said the government would publish its full response next month. The proposals include substantial changes to welfare benefits for under-25s, lower employer National Insurance costs for younger workers, expanded apprenticeships and a new Youth Opportunity Service to coordinate employment, education and health support. Milburn also recommends a legal guarantee of opportunities and support for young people, with additional investment in employment and mental health services.

Speaking to Sky News, Burnham said the review represented an unprecedented effort across government to improve opportunities for young people. “I have never in my years in politics seen a wholesale, whole government approach to supporting the next generation.

“That is what this represents, and I am absolutely confident that I can take this vision and get people behind it, indeed get the country behind it, because we will not place Britain in the position I want it to be in if we have a generation of young people growing up without hope for the future.”

Government urged to reduce hiring costs

Neil Carberry, chief executive of the CIPD, said the review recognised that improving young people’s skills alone would not solve youth unemployment and that businesses needed greater confidence and incentives to offer them opportunities.

“This is a thorough set of recommendations that recognises that youth unemployment requires action from all of us. Milburn has got a key diagnosis right: tackling youth unemployment isn’t just about improving young people’s skills; it’s about giving employers the confidence and incentives to take a chance on young people.”

Carberry welcomed the proposal to reduce employer National Insurance contributions for workers aged 21 to 24, initially in retail and hospitality. The review recommends gradually increasing the threshold at which employers begin paying contributions for these workers from £5,000 to £10,000, potentially saving businesses up to £750 annually for each eligible employee.

But the CIPD argued that restoring the wider employer National Insurance threshold towards its previous £9,100 level would be simpler and provide a greater incentive to create jobs. Carberry also warned that parts of the Employment Rights Act 2025, particularly forthcoming guaranteed-hours reforms, could make employers more reluctant to recruit young people into flexible entry-level positions.

“The new deal that Milburn says is needed between the state and employers is something that businesses across the country will recognise. And employers will be ready to step up – but a deal implies action by both sides. Government cannot simply outsource the risk of success onto employers.”

The Recruitment and Employment Confederation (REC), the trade body representing recruitment businesses, expressed similar concerns. Its interim chief executive, Maxine Bligh, welcomed the proposed incentives but called for wider reductions in employment costs and a reconsideration of guaranteed-hours reforms, which she argued could reduce opportunities for temporary and seasonal employment.

“The government must act quickly in response and focus on restoring employer confidence by making job creation less costly, less risky and less burdensome.”

Bligh said the review gave ministers an opportunity to reconsider the effect of guaranteed-hours legislation on youth employment. The report itself recommends that the government exercise caution when finalising the rules, particularly where they could affect genuinely seasonal and temporary work.

Apprenticeships and recruitment incentives

Milburn’s review proposes a major expansion of apprenticeships and further education, alongside financial incentives designed to make recruiting young people more attractive to businesses. Employers taking on someone aged 16 to 24 who has been NEET for six months would receive £3,000, with additional £2,000 payments proposed for small businesses and for recruiting young people facing greater barriers to employment.

The review also recommends increasing the apprenticeship hiring incentive to £2,500 and creating a pre-apprenticeship pathway to help young people prepare for training and employment. Its longer-term ambition is to reach 270,000 apprenticeship starts annually among under-25s by 2036, supported by changes to the allocation of apprenticeship funding.

The CIPD welcomed the proposals but expressed concern about a recommendation to increase employers’ contributions towards apprenticeships for workers aged 25 and over by 25 percent, with the funding redirected towards younger people. Carberry warned that some businesses could respond by reducing training opportunities for existing older employees.

“We agree that we need to revitalise young apprenticeship learning, ideally with a new Apprenticeship Guarantee, but there is a risk of some employers cutting back on learning for older workers,” he said.

The REC supported redirecting apprenticeship funding towards younger people and called for stronger links between training providers and local labour market needs. Bligh also backed the proposed Youth Opportunity Service, arguing that better work experience, more effective Jobcentre services and closer cooperation with recruitment businesses would be needed to help young people enter employment.

Managers need support to retain young recruits

The Chartered Management Institute (CMI), the professional body for managers and leaders, welcomed the proposals to reduce recruitment costs but warned that getting young people into employment would achieve little without better support from their managers.

CMI chief executive Ann Francke said employers needed to invest in training the people responsible for supervising young recruits, particularly those entering employment without previous workplace experience. She cited figures showing that only 6 percent of managers believed young people had the skills needed to thrive at work, while 80 percent of young workers considered having a trained manager critical to building their confidence.

“Reducing costs for employers when hiring younger workers is a welcome step, as is making more of an effort to provide them with jobs or training opportunities. But getting young people through the door is only half the battle. If we don’t train the managers who are charged with looking after them once they arrive, we won’t see benefits for either the young people or their employers.”

James Reed, chair and chief executive of recruitment company Reed and president of the CMI, said the quality of management could determine whether a young person’s first job became the beginning of a lasting career. He argued that external mentoring should complement, rather than replace, investment in line managers who work directly with young recruits.

“External mentors have their place and can add tremendous value, but they are not a substitute for investing in training the line managers who support young people day in and day out as they learn the ropes and grow in the job,” he said. “We cannot lose sight of those managers if we want these first jobs to become lasting careers.”

Welfare reform and concerns over job quality

Alongside its employment proposals, the review recommends an overhaul of the benefits system for under-25s, including replacing existing health-related support with a new youth allowance and stronger arrangements for those unable to work. The report calls for around £5.8 billion in additional investment by 2036–37, partly funded through changes to welfare spending, with an initial £500 million proposed to begin reforms next year.

The government has backed the review’s overall approach but has not accepted every recommendation. Burnham said a full response would follow consideration of a separate review of Personal Independence Payments by Social Security Minister Sir Stephen Timms, while draft welfare reform proposals are expected early next year. Some Labour MPs and the public service union Unison have warned that reductions in health-related benefits could leave vulnerable young people worse off.

Unite, the trade union representing workers across several industries, welcomed the review’s recognition of the effect of higher employer National Insurance contributions and its support for apprenticeships. But it warned that measures to encourage recruitment must not come at the expense of young workers’ wages or employment protections.

Sharon Graham, Unite’s general secretary, said the government and private industry needed to invest in creating jobs as well as improving access to training. She argued that the review should form part of a wider industrial strategy rather than relying primarily on subsidies to encourage employers to recruit.

“The cost of hiring must not be funded by young workers’ pay packets and delaying the equalisation of minimum wage rates for all adults was not the right way forward,” she said.

Graham also warned against policies that could subsidise poorly paid employment, disadvantage disabled people or support redundancies. Unite opposes lower pay rates for younger workers and wants access to public sector contracts linked to employers providing genuine apprenticeship opportunities.

“We must also be vigilant. It is critical that the government’s response to the Milburn Review avoids creating a race to the bottom for young workers’ pay, subsidising low paid work, punishing disabled people or underwriting redundancies.”

Nearly half of workers fear being judged for not using AI enough

0
The ChatGPT interface showing examples, capabilities and limitations on a dark blue screen

Nearly half of employees worry they will be judged for not using artificial intelligence enough at work, as growing expectations around the technology put pressure on staff to demonstrate that they are keeping pace with changing workplace practices.

A global survey of 3,001 professional employees found that 48 percent were concerned about being judged for insufficient AI use, compared with just 20 percent who worried about being judged for using it. The findings come as AI adoption at work has risen to 74 percent, up from 29 percent in 2024.

The research, conducted by The Inclusion Initiative at the London School of Economics and Political Science (LSE) in collaboration with global consulting firm Protiviti, also found that employees using AI reported saving an average of 19 percent of their working week. However, they reinvested 72 percent of that time in other work, raising concerns that productivity gains could lead to greater workloads rather than less pressure.

The third annual report, Beyond the Technology: Who Really Captures AI’s Gains at Work, examines how employees are responding to AI and whether the time it saves is being used effectively. It found that although the technology is helping people complete tasks more quickly, its growing adoption has not been consistently associated with higher perceived job performance.

AI use brings pressure to do more

More than eight in 10 employees using AI (82 percent) said it helped them complete tasks faster, while 70 percent reported reduced mental effort. Almost two-thirds said it helped automate manual tasks, and 62 percent believed it improved the quality of their work.

Among employees who saved time using AI, 65 percent said they were spending at least moderately more time on higher-value activities. Half reported using the additional capacity to take on new responsibilities or projects.

The findings raise concerns about what the researchers describe as “workload creep”, where the time saved through greater efficiency is absorbed into existing workloads or used to increase expectations of what employees should deliver.

Dr Grace Lordan, founding director of The Inclusion Initiative at LSE, said the growing use of AI was changing workplace expectations and creating pressure for employees to demonstrate their familiarity with the technology.

“AI is becoming an essential part of how we work. But expectations are rising with it. Employees feel pressure to show they are keeping pace with AI while also taking on more,” she said.

“Leaders need to be clear about where AI adds value and how the time it frees should be used. Without that direction, greater efficiency may simply raise the baseline for what employees are expected to deliver. Where those time savings go matters as much as the size of the savings.”

Training linked to greater AI adoption

Access to AI training was associated with substantial differences in how employees used the technology and the amount of time they reported saving.

Among employees who had received AI training, 93 percent said they used the technology at work, compared with 50 percent of those who had not been trained. Even among employees with access to employer-provided AI tools, adoption was higher among those who had received training, at 96 percent compared with 78 percent.

The difference extended to productivity. Employees with AI training reported saving an average of 22 percent of their working hours, compared with 13 percent among those without training. But access to training varied considerably between generations. Two-thirds of Generation Z employees (66 percent) said they had received AI training during the previous year, compared with 40 percent of baby boomers.

The figures indicate that younger employees are receiving more opportunities to develop AI skills, although the research does not establish why the differences exist. They also raise questions about whether employers are providing sufficient support to staff of all ages as the technology becomes more widely used.

The association between training and greater adoption does not necessarily mean training alone caused the differences, but it provides evidence of the importance of helping employees understand how to use AI effectively.

Productivity gains do not guarantee better performance

Despite the reported improvements in efficiency, the researchers found no consistent association between employees’ perceived job performance and their use of AI.

The same was true of AI training, access to in-house tools and the integration of the technology into standardised workflows. Employees who used AI more extensively did not consistently report better job performance than those who used it less.

Instead, higher perceived performance remained associated with qualities including conscientiousness, resilience, confidence in solving problems and a willingness to learn.

The distinction raises questions about how employers measure the success of AI adoption. Although the technology can reduce the time required for particular tasks, that does not necessarily translate into better overall performance or improved outcomes for organisations.

Matt Duncan, managing director at Protiviti, said employers needed to consider how they used the additional capacity created by AI rather than simply expecting staff to complete more work.

“AI is creating meaningful productivity gains, but the bigger opportunity is how organisations use the capacity it creates. Simply absorbing those gains into existing workloads leaves much of AI’s potential untapped.

“Leaders should think deliberately about where that capacity can create the most value, whether that means tackling higher-value work, improving quality or giving employees greater space to solve problems and innovate. The goal shouldn’t just be doing more work faster, but using AI to change what people are able to accomplish.”

Managing expectations around AI

The findings present employers with a challenge as AI becomes a more established part of professional work. Employees increasingly appear to believe they are expected to use the technology, while those already doing so report that much of the time saved is being redirected into additional tasks.

Clear guidance about when AI should be used, what constitutes effective use and how productivity gains should be managed could help organisations avoid creating pressure to adopt the technology simply for its own sake. The differences in training also indicate a need to consider whether employees have equal opportunities to develop relevant skills. Without appropriate support, workers who are less familiar with AI may feel disadvantaged even when their existing performance remains strong.

The research suggests that employers need to look beyond adoption rates and time savings when assessing AI’s contribution to the workplace. How employees use the technology, the quality of their work and the demands placed on them remain important considerations.

The study surveyed 3,001 professional employees globally between March and May 2026. Its findings are based on employees’ reported experiences and perceptions rather than independently measured productivity or job performance.

Young workers offered new route into employment under Milburn reforms

0
Three young peple engaged in a discussion during a meeting in a modern office setting.

Almost 440,000 more young people could be brought into employment or education under sweeping proposals to overhaul Britain’s youth employment and welfare system, including lower hiring costs for businesses, more apprenticeships and guaranteed access to careers support.

Former Labour health secretary Alan Milburn has called for a “complete system reset” to prevent a generation of young people becoming permanently disconnected from work. His government-commissioned review, published on Tuesday, sets out a 10-year programme intended to reduce the proportion of 16- to 24-year-olds not in education, employment or training from approximately 13 percent to 5 percent.

Nearly one million young people are currently outside education, employment and training, with employers facing pressure to provide more opportunities for those struggling to enter the labour market. The proposals include reducing employers’ National Insurance contributions for younger workers, doubling the number of young apprentices and providing additional incentives for businesses to recruit people with limited experience.

The Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD), the professional body for HR and people development, review but warned that the reforms would depend on closer cooperation between government and employers. It said rising employment costs had made businesses more reluctant to recruit, with younger workers bearing much of the impact.

Lower employment costs and more apprenticeships

The review proposes gradually reducing employers’ National Insurance costs for young adults, including doubling the contribution threshold for workers aged 21 to 24 to £10,000. The measure is intended to make recruitment more affordable and encourage businesses to retain younger employees.

It also recommends doubling the number of young apprentices and placing greater emphasis on employment skills throughout the education system. Schools would be expected to prepare pupils more effectively for working life, while further education providers and local organisations would have a greater role in connecting young people with employers.

Neil Carberry, chief executive of the CIPD, said the review presented an opportunity to tackle a problem that had become increasingly difficult for businesses and young people alike.

“This review is a once-in-a-generation chance to turn the tide on youth unemployment, and Alan Milburn and his team deserve thanks for it. But the government will only seize the moment if it backs ambition with genuine partnership with employers and joined-up policy,” he said.

“Too often, decisions are made in silos and leave employers struggling and young people out of work.”

Carberry said employers would welcome measures to reduce recruitment costs, although some changes to the apprenticeship system could create additional financial pressures. He argued that businesses would assess the proposals as a package rather than judging individual measures in isolation.

“This package of reform must signal a fundamental reset in the government’s relationship with business. Milburn’s plan to double the National Insurance threshold for 21-24-year-olds to £10,000 is a welcome recognition that rising employment costs have made hiring harder, and we would encourage the government to follow it.”

New entitlement to employment support

Central to the review is a proposed Youth Opportunity Service in England, which would provide young people with a legal entitlement to personalised employment and education support.

Under the plans, each young person would be assigned a named adviser responsible for helping them secure an apprenticeship, college place, supported employment opportunity or job within four months. The service would bring together support that is currently delivered through different organisations and government programmes.

The review also calls for earlier intervention, beginning before children enter school. It recommends that 90 percent of children should have basic life skills and be ready for school by the age of five, compared with the current figure of 68 percent in England.

Young people experiencing mental health difficulties would be offered immediate access to support without first needing a formal diagnosis. The proposals reflect concerns that health problems, limited qualifications and difficulties accessing appropriate support can prevent young adults from entering employment.

Existing recruitment incentives would continue, including the £3,000 Youth Jobs Grant for employers taking on eligible young people who have been looking for work for six months. The Jobs Guarantee, which funds six months of paid employment, would also remain in place, with eligibility being extended to young adults who have spent 12 months on Universal Credit while seeking work.

Welfare changes raise concerns

The proposed expansion of employment support would be funded partly through substantial changes to welfare benefits for young adults, including replacing existing health-related payments with a new system of allowances.

Under the recommendations, people under 25 would no longer qualify for the health-related Universal Credit top-up or Personal Independence Payment in their current forms. Instead, a Youth Allowance would provide support at the standard Universal Credit rate for younger people, alongside a separate Additional Cost Allowance intended to help with disability-related expenses.

A new Severe and Complex Needs Insurance scheme would support the minority of young people considered unable to work. The proposals have raised concerns about the financial consequences for young adults with disabilities or long-term health conditions, particularly where appropriate employment opportunities are unavailable.

The review estimates that in 2024/25, £25 was spent on youth benefits for every £1 directed towards helping young people into employment or education. Its ambition is to reduce that ratio to £2 of benefits expenditure for every £1 spent on employment support by 2036.

Employers urged to play central role

The CIPD has also called on ministers to reconsider aspects of planned employment law reforms that it believes could discourage businesses from offering flexible entry-level work.

Carberry said the government’s approach to zero-hours contracts needed to recognise that flexible jobs can provide an important first step into employment, particularly for young people balancing work with education or other commitments.

“The government can further show it’s taking a new approach by making sensible compromises on its zero-hours contract reforms, so they don’t threaten the flexible jobs that give many young people their first experience of paid work.”

The proposals have attracted criticism from opposition parties over the pace of reform, the cost of government intervention and the potential impact of changes to disability benefits.

Conservative shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately said parts of the review were too cautious and relied excessively on public spending. Liberal Democrat deputy leader Daisy Cooper called for more work experience opportunities and careers guidance, while the Greens expressed concern about reducing financial support for vulnerable young people.

The immediate question for employers is whether lower recruitment costs and stronger local employment services would make it easier to take on young workers who lack experience or need additional support. The review’s recommendations are not yet government policy, and their impact will depend on which measures ministers adopt, how they are funded and whether businesses respond by creating more opportunities.

Carberry said achieving lasting improvements would require measures that worked for employees and employers alike.

“Getting to solutions that are pro-worker and pro-business will be key. The CIPD is ready to step up and play our part in building more and better pathways into work for young people.”

UK job vacancies fall to 12-year low as employers cut hiring

0
People walking along the Thames in London with City skyscrapers in the background.

UK job vacancies have fallen to their lowest level outside the pandemic since 2014, with smaller businesses accounting for the largest reduction as rising employment and operating costs continue to affect recruitment decisions.

The number of vacancies fell by 22,000 to 690,000 in the three months to October, a decline of 3 percent on the previous quarter, according to figures published by the Office for National Statistics (ONS) on Tuesday. Vacancies were also down by 37,000, or 5 percent, compared with the same period last year.

The figures show that businesses employing one to nine people recorded a particularly sharp fall, with vacancies dropping by 22,000 to 73,000. Outside the pandemic, the last time vacancies among these smaller employers were this low was in 2012.

Payroll employment also declined, with provisional figures showing 34,000 fewer employees in October than in September. The total fell to 30.2 million, some 95,000 below the level recorded a year earlier, adding to evidence that employers are exercising greater caution over recruitment.

Smaller firms bear the brunt of hiring slowdown

The decline in vacancies was recorded across 11 of the 18 industry sectors measured by the ONS. Administrative and support services, construction and transport and storage experienced the largest quarterly falls, each recording 5,000 fewer vacancies.

The reduction was particularly pronounced among the smallest employers, whose vacancy numbers fell to a level last recorded outside the pandemic in April to June 2012. The ONS said feedback from its Vacancy Survey indicated that labour costs and wider economic conditions were affecting recruitment decisions among smaller businesses.

Liz McKeown, director of economic statistics at the ONS, said employers were continuing to reduce recruitment opportunities, with the pressure concentrated among businesses facing higher costs.

“Over the same period, the number of workers on payroll fell. Vacancies also fell further, with the decline again concentrated in smaller businesses, which report that increased labour and operating costs are affecting their hiring decisions,” she said.

Meanwhile, Keith Rosser, chair of the Better Hiring Institute, an organisation working to improve recruitment standards and practices, told HRreview that the figures reflected growing pressure on employers to reconsider how they filled vacancies.

“Despite the latest figures showing slightly increased employment and falling unemployment rates in the latest quarter, they continue to highlight the growing pressures on the UK’s jobs market. As employment costs rise, businesses are increasingly considering alternatives to recruitment, including fractional work, automation, AI and offshoring.”

Wage growth slows as public sector pay increases ease

Annual growth in regular earnings, excluding bonuses, slowed to 3.5 percent in the three months to September, down from 3.7 percent in the previous three-month period. Total earnings growth, including bonuses, fell from 3.8 percent to 3.6 percent. The ONS said the latest figure was the lowest since August to October 2020, when annual growth stood at 2.8 percent.

The slowdown in regular pay growth was largely driven by the public sector, where the annual rate fell to 5.4 percent. Private sector regular earnings increased by 3.1 percent over the year.

McKeown said the timing of public sector pay awards had affected the figures, with the influence of earlier increases beginning to diminish.

“Meanwhile, regular wage growth slowed, driven by a fall in public sector wage growth, as the recent impact from the timing of pay awards has started to drop out of the numbers.”

After accounting for inflation using the Consumer Prices Index including owner occupiers’ housing costs, regular earnings increased by just 0.2 percent in real terms. Total earnings rose by 0.3 percent, indicating that employees experienced only modest improvements in purchasing power over the period.

Using the Consumer Prices Index, which excludes owner occupiers’ housing costs, real regular earnings growth was 0.4 percent and total earnings growth was 0.6 percent.

Employment rises despite falling payroll numbers

The figures also revealed an apparent improvement in the headline employment and unemployment rates, although the ONS cautioned against interpreting the movements as evidence of a substantial strengthening in the labour market. The UK employment rate for people aged 16 to 64 rose to 75.4 percent in July to September, an increase of 0.3 percentage points on the previous quarter and 0.4 percentage points on the year.

Unemployment fell to 4.6 percent, down 0.3 percentage points on both the quarter and the year. The economic inactivity rate also declined slightly to 20.8 percent, while the number of people claiming unemployment-related benefits rose to an estimated 1.714 million in October.

The ONS explained that the changes in employment and unemployment were partly influenced by differences between groups entering and leaving the Labour Force Survey, rather than solely reflecting changes in labour market conditions.

McKeown said the figures needed to be considered together because different measures were showing contrasting developments.

“The latest figures provide a mixed picture overall. The employment rate increased and the unemployment rate fell in the latest quarter, though these movements partly reflect particularly large differences in employment status between the groups entering and leaving the survey.”

The ONS said the group leaving the survey had unusually low employment and high unemployment compared with other recent respondents. Its replacement therefore contributed to the improvement in the headline rates, making it important to consider payroll data and vacancies alongside the survey estimates.

AI recruitment risks growing as vacancies decline

The reduction in available jobs is also raising concerns about how employers and candidates use artificial intelligence during recruitment, particularly as competition for vacancies intensifies.

Rosser warned that the growing use of automated tools by both applicants and employers could make recruitment processes more complicated without necessarily improving hiring decisions.

“With fewer opportunities available, it’s more important than ever that employers can find the right people quickly and effectively. Yet we risk creating an AI arms race in recruitment, with candidates using technology to apply for more jobs and employers using it to filter more applications, without necessarily improving outcomes for either side.”

His comments reflect concerns that employers facing higher recruitment costs may increasingly turn to technology to manage applications, while candidates use similar tools to apply for larger numbers of vacancies. The result could be greater volumes of applications and automated screening without corresponding improvements in matching candidates to suitable positions.

“The danger is that we’re making a broken recruitment system faster, rather than better at connecting the right people with the right jobs,” Rosser said.

The latest labour market figures present a difficult picture for businesses planning their recruitment and workforce budgets. Although unemployment has fallen, employers are advertising fewer vacancies and payroll employment has declined, particularly among smaller organisations.

Slower wage growth may ease some pressure on employers’ pay budgets, but employees are receiving only modest increases in earnings after inflation. HR teams are therefore balancing recruitment costs, employee retention and pay expectations against uncertain labour market conditions.

The ONS cautioned that short-term movements in its Labour Force Survey should be interpreted carefully because of continuing volatility in some estimates. October’s payroll employment figures are also provisional and may be revised when further information becomes available.

The next UK labour market figures are scheduled for publication on 15 December.

Workers ‘cross blue-white collar divide’ but employers limit career moves

0
People on a modern multi-level staircase in an office.

Workers are increasingly moving between traditionally blue-collar and white-collar jobs, but many believe their employers are failing to provide opportunities to make similar career changes within their organisations, new international research has found.

More than eight in 10 blue-collar workers, at 81 percent, have worked in a white-collar role at some point in their careers, while 74 percent of white-collar employees have experience of blue-collar work. Yet only 61 percent believe their current employer would give them a genuine opportunity to move between hands-on and office-based positions.

The research, involving more than 10,000 employees across 15 countries, also identified a gap between job satisfaction and workers’ confidence in their future prospects. Although 85 percent said they were satisfied with their current role, 41 percent were considering leaving or actively looking for another job.

The study was conducted for Top Employers Institute, an international organisation that assesses and certifies employers’ people management practices. Its report, Beyond Collar Colours: Building more mobile, secure, and resilient workforces, examines how traditional occupational categories influence career development, employee retention and access to new opportunities.

Traditional career boundaries becoming less relevant

The distinction between blue-collar and white-collar employment has traditionally separated manual and practical work from office-based and professional occupations. But the research indicates that many employees no longer follow career paths confined to one category, with substantial numbers having experience of both.

Among blue-collar workers, 59 percent believed the two types of employment were similar in many respects, compared with 56 percent of white-collar employees. Almost a third of all respondents, at 32 percent, said they would prefer to work in the opposite category if the pay were equal.

Despite this willingness to consider different kinds of employment, formal career structures can restrict movement between roles. Among workers who did not believe they had a realistic opportunity to change categories within their current organisation, 35 percent of blue-collar employees and 33 percent of white-collar staff cited the absence of a formal process.

The Institute said the distinction between workers with opportunities to develop new skills and those who felt confined to their existing roles was becoming increasingly important. It argued that organisations needed to make career progression possible across different types of work rather than treating manual and office-based positions as separate career paths.

Sebastiaan ter Horst, chief certification and insights officer at the Institute, said employers should not assume that satisfaction with a current position meant employees were confident about their longer-term prospects.

“Employers who think satisfaction with a current job equals an employee having confidence in their future prospects should take note.

“This research shows it is dangerous to pigeon-hole workers as ‘blue-collar’ or ‘white-collar’ with entirely separate career paths and structures. Instead, a new divide is emerging across both groups: between those who feel confident in their ability to adapt and progress and those who feel their options are limited.”

Job satisfaction does not guarantee retention

The research found that employees could be satisfied with their current responsibilities while remaining uncertain about their future employment opportunities. The 41 percent considering leaving or actively seeking another job included workers who were otherwise content in their existing positions.

The study also identified differences in how easily employees believed they could find alternative employment. Just 18 percent of white-collar workers thought it would be extremely easy to secure an equally good job elsewhere within three months, compared with 28 percent of blue-collar employees.

The Institute described one group as “stuck white-collar professionals”, whose relatively low intention to leave may reflect limited confidence in finding another suitable position. The research suggests that remaining with an employer does not necessarily indicate strong commitment or satisfaction with future career opportunities.

The report identified five workforce profiles based on employees’ experiences and career prospects, including workers who had already moved between occupational categories and those facing barriers to doing so. It also examined the pressures affecting blue-collar employees experiencing staff shortages and older workers whose access to development opportunities had declined.

Staff shortages add to pressures

Among blue-collar workers, 70 percent reported that staff shortages had increased over the previous year. Of those experiencing greater shortages, 58 percent said they had considered leaving their jobs as a result, indicating that workload pressures could be contributing to retention difficulties.

The research also identified particular challenges for experienced blue-collar employees, with access to development declining sharply from the age of 45. Despite these barriers, many older workers continued to take considerable pride in their work, including 80 percent of blue-collar employees aged 65 and over who valued seeing the physical results of their efforts.

Employees earlier in their careers expressed different priorities. Among those with fewer than 11 years of experience, 72 percent said they valued flexibility over financial reward, indicating that opportunities to control working schedules could be an important consideration when choosing or remaining in a job.

The Institute said these differences meant organisations needed to consider employees’ circumstances and career stages when designing development opportunities. Workers facing heavy workloads may struggle to undertake training, while experienced employees can find their opportunities restricted despite having valuable knowledge and skills.

Ter Horst said businesses should make future career opportunities more visible and ensure employees had practical support to develop new capabilities.

“These findings challenge employers to make the next career step visible and accessible. Job security and career security both matter. Employers can strengthen career confidence by making future skill requirements clear, expecting managers to support moves across teams and keeping development open throughout working life.

“For employees already stretched by shortages, that support must also include manageable workloads and protected time to learn.”

Greater opportunities for career mobility

The report recommends introducing more opportunities for employees to experience different kinds of work, including job shadowing and secondments between hands-on and office-based roles. It also calls for managers to be recognised for helping employees develop careers across the wider organisation rather than retaining talent within their own teams.

Other recommendations include providing continued development opportunities for older employees and redesigning roles to accommodate changing capabilities and career expectations. The institute also urged organisations to address excessive workloads so that employees had sufficient time to participate in training and adapt to workplace changes.

The research was conducted by pollster Opinion Matters between 11 August and 3 September 2026 among 10,181 employees working for organisations with at least 1,000 staff. Respondents came from 15 countries, including the UK, the US, Germany, France, India and China, and represented 13 industry sectors.

Of those surveyed, 5,124 identified as blue-collar workers and 5,057 as white-collar employees. Overall results were weighted to give each country equal representation, while demographic breakdowns were unweighted, meaning the figures describe an international workforce rather than UK employees specifically.

Kiran Kapur: Apprenticeships – Are you making the best use of government-sponsored training?

0

From 1 October small businesses receive £2,000 for each 16–24-year-old apprentice they recruit, so long as they have joined their employer within the last three months. This is in addition to the existing financial incentives which include £1,000 to support apprentices in the workplace at the start of their training for young apprentices.

Crucially, there is no contribution to paying towards the training costs. The government will fully fund training for all apprentices under the age of 25. For older apprentices, over the age of 25, smaller employers will have to cover just 5% of training costs. The UK government provides apprenticeship funding for larger businesses via its Apprenticeship Levy. Apprenticeships within levy paying businesses are fully funded out of their levy pot.

Many employers are expecting their use of apprenticeships to grow. A survey of 800 businesses by industry body St Martin’s Group in June found that 61% of businesses expect their usage of apprenticeships to increase over the next two years.

So what should HR leaders know about apprenticeships?

How do apprenticeships work?

Apprenticeships combine practical, on-the-job experience with formal study and qualifications. They work within the business and spend at least six hours per week training  and studying. Programs last from eight months to six years, with most lasting between 12 and 24 months. Qualification levels range from the equivalent of GCSEs through to Masters Degree level.

The study and off-the job training is provided by a training provider. Many of these providers will also have an affiliation with a professional body and may offer a formal qualification from that body as part of the apprenticeship.

What types of apprenticeships are out there?

There are currently 939 different government-sponsored apprenticeships available across a massive range of job roles and industries. They are officially divided into seven different levels based on the educational standard they match and can be suitable for a range of individuals from school leavers through to senior leadership roles.

How apprenticeships can be used to help address pain points?

Schools, degrees and other traditional education routes often leave those leaving education with plenty of theoretical knowledge, but with little practical day-to-day work skills.

Some employers have traditionally tackled this with graduate and school leaver training programmes, but these are expensive and time-consuming for HR teams to run.

Apprenticeships can act as a solution to this problem, offering a structured way to recruit, train, and retain talent. By blending on-the-job training with learning, when properly implemented they directly target and close specific internal skill gaps.

One recent survey of 800 employers found an increased preference among hiring managers for apprenticeship learners over graduate programme recruits. This was driven by increased retention within the business and lower costs.

Cheaper than in-house training programs, apprenticeships can still be tailored to your specific business needs. Apprentices learn your systems, software, and workflows from day one, alongside specifically selected and targeted training addressing any skill-gaps you may have, ensuring their skills perfectly align with your business objectives.

Recent research from industry body St Martin’s Group found that the ability to bespoke apprenticeships to individual business needs is one of the largest advantages of the apprenticeship system. Many employers reported that there is often no viable external recruitment market for critical operational and technical roles, requiring organisations to ‘grow their own’ talent via apprenticeships over a period of years.

Research has also shown that employees who enter a business through an apprenticeship are more likely to feel valued, and say that they can see a clear, structured pathway for career progression. Overall retention rates for those who entered businesses via an apprenticeship are higher than other routes as a result.

Using apprenticeships to upskill and retain existing workers?

When many people think of apprenticeships, they think purely of entry-level roles into a profession. This is no longer the case.

Recent UK skills reforms have increased the number of options available for more experienced workers including accelerated qualifications. Apprenticeships are now commonly being used to either upskill or reskill existing team members in specialist areas such as artificial intelligence.

A recent survey of 800 employers found that 79% had increased their use of apprenticeships for upskilling and reskilling existing employees over the last two years. Half of those surveyed (50%) said they expected this to increase further.

By offering apprenticeships to existing employees you are also demonstrating an investment in their professional development, fostering staff loyalty and reducing turnover.

Up to three quarters (78%) of the employers surveyed by the St Martin’s Group reported improved productivity and higher product/service quality after having introduced apprenticeships. It has also shown that wider team members often feel more energized and motivated by mentoring and supporting apprentices.

Hiring apprentices can also boost your company and brand image. Businesses that offer apprenticeships can benefit from a strong reputation as it demonstrates a commitment to talent development and tackling the problem of young people not employed or in education.

What can an apprentice bring to the table?

Apprentices receive structured training and real-world experience, providing a cost-effective way for a business to build valuable skills within their workforce. They bring fresh ideas, new skills and up-to-date knowledge without the high costs of hiring experienced professionals.

The skills an apprentice can gain from a qualification will mean they can work faster and with more skill. This will not only help them excel at their job, but can also result in the company reaching its business goals more efficiently, providing a valuable return on investment.

The apprentice will also often spread their new knowledge, multiplying the benefits for their team.

How do I go about finding the right apprenticeship provider?

There are a wide range of apprenticeship providers out there, with varied levels of specialisms and different ways of learning.

Like many forms of training, choosing the right provider is a case finding the right match between provider, learners needs and employer needs.

The most obvious difference between providers is how they engage with learners. Some providers offer in-person training, either within a college-style environment or at specialist manual-skill-focused training centers. Others offer entirely online based learning, with apprentices either learning from home or from the workplace during their training hours.

Every individual learner is different but if I had to generalize I would say that in-person learning is generally most beneficial where manual-focused skills are being learnt or where younger apprentices may benefit from in-person supervision and assistance. Where an apprentice is more self-motivated, and is working within an office environment, online learning can offer more flexibility for both apprentice and employer as training can be done at a time that best suits.

Another point to closely consider when choosing a provider is what kind of tutor you would most benefit from your apprentice learning their skills from. Some providers’ tutor lists will include those who have spent their careers in higher education, and others will have a focus on learning from experienced practitioners in their field of study. Whichever approach your apprentice and business would benefit most from, you should take a close look at the providers’ tutor list for the course in question, and ensure they are experienced not just qualified.

Is it hard to manage an apprentice?

When talking to employers who are considering taking on an apprentice, one of the most common concerns we hear mentioned is how much support the apprentice will need during the training.

Managing an apprentice is very similar to managing any other younger team member, with setting clear goals, developing a work schedule, and providing opportunities for mentorship being especially important. Management needs to be adapted to the style of the individual manager and apprentice. Scheduling regular and structured 1:1 sessions to provide feedback is especially important for apprentices as many will new to the workplace.

The one area where people management differs for the successful management of an apprentice is helping to keep them on track with their learning. Whilst it could be argued that this is for the apprentice to self-motivate, the most successful manager-apprentice relationships involve helping them protect their off-the-job training time within working hours and monitoring how effectively the apprentice is using this time.

Whilst your training provider should provide regular feedback on how your apprentice is progressing with their learning, checking in directly via structured 1:1s dedicated to training progress can be extremely valuable.

What can HR managers do to help support managers of apprentices?

The government has recently made changes to the apprenticeship assessment system to make assessment plans, shorter, clearer, and with greater focus on core assessment outcomes. It claims the new system will also provide more flexibility for employers.

The one area of training under the new Apprenticeship Assessment system that employers will be responsible for is to ‘verify apprentice behaviors are demonstrated in the workplace’. Previously this responsibility had been shared with the training provider so in theory employers may now find themselves taking on greater responsibility for assessing their apprentices than expected.

HR manager can be especially helpful here by getting to grips with the changes to the apprenticeship assessment system and helping managers understand what they need to do to measure behaviours and what responsibilities they have under the new verification system.

These are some of the most significant changes we have seen to the apprenticeship system over the past decade, but very few employers have had time to get to grips with what it means for them and their apprentices. The changes have been communicated by the Government in a very technical manner, which for some HR leaders will have added an extra layer of impenetrability to what is already a complex system.

Overall the new system could offer some major benefits for employers. Under the new system apprentices start on their first company-based live projects earlier in their training. This gives employers a chance to benefit from projects at an earlier stage in the apprenticeship, along with the expertise that the apprentice’s tutor brings to the company-based initiatives.

Bitesize training

Interested in providing training but not quite ready to commit to a whole apprenticeship? You should consider Apprenticeship Units.

Launched by the Government in April 2026, Apprenticeship Units are short flexible training courses designed to help employers to upskill their workforce in critical skill shortage areas. Any employee over the age of 19 can be eligible.

Training is on specific areas where there are commonly skill gaps, ideal for the rapid upskilling of experienced staff. As such they are shorter than an apprenticeship, typically taking 30 to 140 hours of learning to complete.

One of the great pieces of news about these units are that smaller, non-levy-paying, businesses are able to train their staff for free. No payment is needed from employer or employee to access these government-sponsored units.

For larger employers, businesses who already pay into the Apprenticeship Levy can use existing funds to cover this training.

How to get started

You have learnt how apprenticeships can contribute to the long-term skills development of teams throughout your organisation, but where should you start?

First you need to identify what knowledge, skills and abilities are needed to help your teams meet their objectives, and those of the business as a whole. Work with your team managers to do an organizational needs analysis and compare that to your current training resources.

Once you have identified those gaps, you need to decide if it is a case of upskilling existing workers, hiring a new apprentice, or a combination of the above.

Once you have an idea about what could be best for your organisation, it is time to look for apprenticeship providers who specialise in that area. Not only can they provide the external training needed, they can also often help guide you through the process of gaining government funding.

Workers ‘hide second jobs from employers’ as financial pressures mount

0
A Deliveroo rider on a bike in a busy London street.

More than four in 10 people with side hustles have concealed their additional work from their employers, while almost as many admit pursuing other business activities during the hours they are supposed to be working in their main jobs, according to research into the growing importance of second incomes.

The study found that 41 percent of people with side hustles had kept them secret from their employers, while 39 percent said they worked on their additional ventures during their main job’s working hours. Among millennials, the proportion undertaking side-hustle activities during their primary employment rose to 46 percent, raising questions about working time, performance and potential conflicts of interest.

Financial pressures appear to be a major factor behind the growth of additional work, with half of respondents relying on side-hustle earnings to help cover essential household expenses. Six in 10 said the rising cost of living had made their second income more important, while 54 percent reported that it had become more financially significant over the previous year.

The research was conducted by polling company Censuswide among 1,006 UK adults with side hustles in July 2026, on behalf of Markel Direct, a specialist small business insurer. Because the survey covered people already undertaking additional work, it doesn’t establish how common side hustles are among the wider UK workforce.

Second incomes become essential to household finances

Financial security was cited by 33 percent of respondents as a reason for starting a side hustle, while 32 percent identified the rising cost of living. The figures indicate that additional employment and self-employment are providing financial support for people whose primary earnings may not be sufficient to meet their needs.

More than half of respondents, 52 percent, expected their side-hustle income to become more important for covering essential expenses over the next three years. This suggests that many are planning to maintain their additional work rather than treating it as a temporary arrangement, even where it creates competing demands on their time.

The wider research found that people with side hustles earned an average of £700.50 a month from their additional activities, spending almost 16 hours a week on them. That represents a substantial commitment alongside a main job, particularly where individuals are already working full-time or have caring responsibilities.

The financial benefits can also come at a personal cost. Some 44 percent reported experiencing burnout from juggling their commitments, while almost half said they had sacrificed sleep or downtime to accommodate their additional work. Another 46 percent had worked on their side hustles during annual leave, potentially reducing opportunities to recover from their main employment.

Employers face questions over undisclosed work

The finding that 41 percent had concealed their side hustles from employers raises questions about how organisations communicate policies on secondary employment. Some workers may be concerned that disclosure could affect their career prospects, while others may not understand whether their contracts require them to declare additional paid activities.

Among millennials surveyed, 50 percent said they had hidden a side hustle from their employer. The figure was higher than the overall average, suggesting that attitudes towards combining employment with independent business activities may vary between generations.

Holding a second job or operating a business alongside employment is not inherently unlawful, and many people undertake additional work without breaching their contractual obligations. Problems can arise where the activities create conflicts of interest, involve competing businesses, compromise confidentiality or interfere with the performance of duties during contracted working hours.

That almost four in 10 respondents undertake side-hustle activities during their main working hours is particularly relevant to employers managing remote and hybrid teams. But the survey does not establish how much paid working time is involved, whether employees have flexible schedules or whether the additional activities have affected their performance.

The figures also need to be distinguished from recent cases of public sector employees fraudulently concealing multiple full-time jobs. Legitimate freelance work, small businesses and occasional paid activities are materially different from deliberately making false employment declarations or receiving salaries for incompatible contractual commitments.

Financial strain and the cost of additional work

The research also raises questions about the relationship between financial wellbeing and employee performance. Workers who depend on second incomes to meet essential expenses may be reluctant to reduce their additional commitments, even when the resulting workload affects their health or their ability to rest.

Almost half of respondents, 48 percent, said they had sacrificed sleep, rest or downtime to maintain their side hustles, while 38 percent reported a negative effect on their work-life balance. The figures point to pressures that may not be immediately apparent to employers, particularly where employees have chosen not to disclose their additional activities.

Financial pressures appear to be a stronger motivation for taking on additional work than ambitions to become self-employed. Although 23 percent started their side hustles with the intention of eventually working for themselves, financial security and living costs were more commonly cited reasons.

There are also indications that some workers may ultimately leave their main employment to pursue their independent businesses. Some 43 percent said they would do so if the opportunity arose, rising to 50 percent among millennials, while 52 percent regarded their side hustle as part of their long-term future.

Rob Rees, a divisional director at Markel Direct, the business insurance specialist behind the research, said the growing reliance on secondary income brought additional risks for people running businesses alongside their main employment.

“Side hustles are becoming an important source of income for many people, but as these ventures grow, so do the risks,” he said.

“Whether someone is selling second-hand products, offering creative services or building a craft business, they may be exposed to allegations of injury, property damage or sub-standard services that cause a customer a financial loss.”

Ambrose Bierce on the art of dodging corporate responsibility

0
Ambrose Bierce

“An ingenious device for obtaining individual profit without individual responsibility.”

Context

Corporate responsibility is a phrase that appears regularly in annual reports, company policies and statements of organisational values. Yet when something goes badly wrong, identifying the individual responsible can prove remarkably difficult. Decisions pass through committees, departments and management structures until accountability becomes everybody’s concern but nobody’s particular obligation.

The American journalist, author and satirist Ambrose Bierce recognised this contradiction more than a century ago. In The Devil’s Dictionary, published in book form in 1911, he offered a collection of wickedly cynical definitions that exposed the gap between respectable language and less respectable human behaviour.

His definition of a corporation was characteristically merciless: “An ingenious device for obtaining individual profit without individual responsibility.”

Bierce was writing during an era of expanding American corporate power, when large businesses were transforming the economy and provoking arguments about wealth, influence and accountability. His observation was not a technical description of company law but a satirical attack on the way corporate structures could separate personal financial gain from personal responsibility.

Meaning

The humour lies in Bierce’s treatment of a familiar business institution as though its principal purpose were to allow people to enjoy the benefits of success while escaping the consequences of failure. What might ordinarily be presented as an efficient arrangement for organising commercial activity becomes, in his telling, a remarkably convenient means of avoiding blame.

There’s an important distinction between the legal responsibilities of a corporation and the behaviour of the people who manage it. Limited liability has legitimate economic purposes, allowing businesses to raise capital and undertake ventures that might otherwise be impossible. Bierce’s criticism is aimed at the moral temptation that can accompany such arrangements.

That temptation is not confined to company directors or shareholders. Within organisations, responsibility can become blurred whenever decisions are attributed to a process, a policy or an unnamed group rather than to the people who made them.

An unpopular restructuring might be described as a business necessity. An unfair promotion decision may be explained as the outcome of a collective assessment. A damaging workplace culture can persist because everyone acknowledges the problem but nobody accepts sufficient responsibility to change it.

The language of organisational decision-making can make these explanations sound reasonable, even when the people affected have little opportunity to question them.

Implications

Accountability becomes particularly important when decisions affect employees’ livelihoods, wellbeing and opportunities. A company may have detailed procedures governing recruitment, performance management, disciplinary action and redundancy, but those procedures offer limited protection if nobody can explain how a decision was reached or who is answerable for it.

Consider a workplace where bullying complaints are repeatedly passed between managers, or where employees receive conflicting explanations for decisions about pay and promotion. The existence of formal processes does not necessarily mean that anyone is taking ownership of the underlying problem.

Senior leaders set the tone. When executives accept credit for successful initiatives but attribute failures to circumstances, systems or colleagues, that behaviour can spread through the organisation. Managers further down the hierarchy may become more concerned with protecting themselves than with making sound decisions.

The consequences extend beyond individual grievances. Employees who believe that senior figures are insulated from the effects of their decisions may become reluctant to report problems, challenge questionable practices or trust assurances about fairness and transparency.

Clear decision-making responsibilities, consistent treatment and a willingness to acknowledge mistakes can help prevent this. Accountability also requires organisations to examine whether their systems genuinely allow concerns to be addressed, rather than simply directing complaints through an elaborate sequence of procedures.

Bierce’s definition remains funny because it is so uncomfortably recognisable. More than a century after he wrote it, businesses have developed increasingly sophisticated language around governance, ethics and responsibility. But his underlying question remains remarkably simple: when an organisation benefits from a decision, who takes the credit, and when that decision causes harm, who accepts the blame?