Ruby Kite knows that building a successful business involves more than recruiting talented people. As vice-president of people at The PHA Group, an independent creative communications agency, she oversees HR across its UK operations and expanding US business, where differing employment laws, workplace expectations and commercial pressures all demand careful attention. Having joined the agency more than seven years ago, she has progressed from internal recruitment and inclusion initiatives to leading its entire People function.
The 32-year-old lives in Hertfordshire with her husband and their nearly two-year-old son, while her working life centres on Covent Garden in London. Her career began at a specialist public relations recruitment agency before she moved to PHA, then her favourite client. Now advising the chief executive and senior leadership team, she has recently overhauled performance and reward frameworks, career pathways and HR systems, while helping the agency manage international growth.
For Kite, good HR is as much about challenging commercial decisions as supporting employees. She considers why traditional approaches to promotion can disadvantage talented specialists, how employers can tackle the working conditions behind burnout and what AI could mean for junior employees in creative industries. She also examines the practical implications of employment law reform and why HR needs to be involved in business decisions before problems arise.
The PHA Group has expanded into the US, adding to its UK operations. What have been the biggest people challenges in supporting international growth, particularly when employment practices and workplace expectations differ between countries?
One of the biggest challenges for a business expanding from the UK has been navigating how employment rights and benefits vary across US states and sometimes even between cities. We also have two separate US entities, adding another layer to decisions about payroll, benefits and policies, which means each hire or relocation needs careful consideration.
In the UK, we’ve had years to develop our policies and processes as legislation and the business have evolved. Building a similarly dependable foundation across the US has meant learning quickly, working closely with local providers and knowing where specialist advice is needed. Time differences of up to eight hours also make planning and communication particularly important.
That work has made us more deliberate about what employees should experience consistently across the business and where arrangements need to reflect local requirements and expectations. Our people need to understand how to access support, what’s expected of them and how they can develop, wherever they’re based.
For me, the reward is seeing that groundwork support closer collaboration between UK and US colleagues. Reliable processes make it easier to support each new employee and help teams work together as the business grows.
How do you balance the commercial demands of a fast-paced communications agency with employees’ expectations around workload, flexibility and work-life balance?
I think the balance starts with what we agree to deliver to our clients. If we consistently promise more than a team can reasonably achieve, the pressure will eventually show up in their working hours and quality of work. There’ll always be urgent requests, last-minute pitches and crises, but we’re responsible for deciding how we respond and what needs to change elsewhere.
To support this, managers need to resource accounts accordingly and make decisions when priorities compete. Employees also have a responsibility to manage their time and flag concerns early. Timesheets can be helpful for both parties to identify where pressure is recurring, with accurate records depending on employees seeing that the information leads to action.
My role in this is to give employees regular opportunities to raise any issues and support them in finding a way forward with their manager. It’s also to make sure our policies and benefits support flexibility and work-life balance, and that people feel able to use them. Low uptake can be a warning sign that something isn’t working in practice, whether that’s workload, awareness or concern about how using a benefit might be perceived.
At 32, you’ve already reached a senior HR leadership position. Have you encountered assumptions about age and experience, and what advice would you give younger HR professionals aspiring to executive roles?
Age hasn’t been a barrier I’ve personally encountered. I’ve been at PHA for over seven years and benefited greatly from managers who shared their knowledge of the business, including decisions and experiences that predated me. Working across talent, culture, inclusion and People in that time has also given me different perspectives on how the agency operates in practice, helping me recognise what we can build on and where we need to improve.
My advice to HR professionals earlier in their career would be to get close to the work your colleagues do. HR can be a solitary role, particularly when you’re balancing several issues simultaneously and you are the only constant. Getting under the skin of people’s responsibilities, how teams depend on each other and the challenges they face at each level makes your advice more relevant. It also gives you the confidence to challenge decisions and offer practical alternatives because you understand how they’ll affect people’s day-to-day work.
I’d also encourage younger professionals to practise making recommendations before they feel completely ready by explaining what you’d do, why you’d do it and what trade-offs it would involve. It’s also important to be open about where you need to seek specialist advice or a second perspective. You build trust both by showing how you’ve reached a view and that you’re willing to reconsider it; habits you can develop long before you have a senior title.
“Employees shouldn’t have to work out which version of success applies to them based on who manages them.”
PHA has introduced transparent career pathways and structured promotion processes. How do you ensure performance and promotion decisions are genuinely fair, particularly when managers may have very different ideas about what good performance looks like?
If managers have fundamentally different ideas about good performance, I’d question how clearly the business has communicated its expectations. Employees shouldn’t have to work out which version of success applies to them based on who manages them. They should have an understanding of what the business is trying to achieve, how their contribution fits with the broader vision and which behaviours are expected or unacceptable.
Meanwhile, the employee value proposition needs to show up in what leaders recognise, reward and challenge. If we say we value collaboration but consistently reward individual results regardless of how they’re achieved, employees will notice and question whether it’s a business they want to be a part of.
A year ago, we undertook a sizeable project to ensure job descriptions and career pathways translate those expectations into responsibilities at each level. This included consolidating job titles where the distinction between roles was difficult to justify. We also moved to a bi-annual performance cycle, with our April and October reviews giving us a consistent opportunity to consider employees across teams, including those less likely to push for a promotion or pay rise. Reviewing leadership’s recommendations together lets us challenge differences in managers’ assessments.
We take a similarly structured approach to pay, drawing on the Living Wage Foundation’s annual announcement, salary surveys conducted by specialist recruiters and advertised roles to conduct a bi-annual benchmarking exercise.
Is the traditional annual performance appraisal becoming outdated, and what would a more effective approach to managing performance look like?
I don’t think the annual appraisal is outdated, but rather that its value depends on everything that happens around it. Employees need clear expectations, access to progression opportunities and a manager who gives useful feedback throughout the year. If those foundations are weak, adding more appraisal meetings can become a business’s way of compensating for them.
When I joined PHA, quarterly appraisals had recently been introduced because performance conversations were happening too infrequently. While they were useful in facilitating more regular performance discussions with managers, over time they became a box-ticking exercise and started to revolve largely around the timing of the next promotion. This resulted in objectives becoming narrower and more immediate, with less connection to the agency’s wider priorities.
We’ve since returned to an annual appraisal, enabling a longer view of performance and development, supported by quarterly check-ins that help employees track progress against their objectives, address challenges and feel supported. We find five prompts helpful in the quarterly conversations. Connect asks how someone is feeling about work. Celebrate highlights what’s going well. Challenge explores what’s getting in the way. Champion focuses on how their manager can support them. Commit sets out what each person has agreed to do next.
As the Employment Rights Act brings changes to workplace protections, which reforms do you think will have the greatest practical impact on employers, and where do you foresee the biggest implementation challenges?
I expect the unfair dismissal reforms taking effect on January 1st 2027 to have the greatest practical impact. As a result of the qualifying period for ordinary unfair dismissal falling from two years to six months and the cap on compensatory awards being removed, employers will need to look closely at how they manage hiring, onboarding and probation processes. Will we see as many ambitious growth roles, where businesses hire ahead of demand to support future expansion? Or extended probations beyond six months for those who need more time and support? I suspect not.
Another potential challenge is that much of the implementation will depend on line managers. HR can’t be present for every conversation, email or decision, yet those interactions can become important evidence in a dispute. Employers will need to provide practical training, arrange regular check-ins and make clear when managers should involve HR before concerns escalate.
I’m also concerned about the combined impact of employment reforms and rising minimum wage rates on entry-level opportunities. While it’s vital that salaries reflect the cost of living, businesses need to fund those increases alongside the time spent training new starters with no experience. With limited budgets and management capacity, paying slightly more for a second jobber may become a more attractive option, so HR teams and business leaders will need to spend time considering how they can meet stronger employment standards while continuing to give school leavers and graduates their first opportunity.
“We risk creating a workforce of human AI agents passing on outputs [staff] haven’t learned to question.”
Creative agencies depend on fresh ideas and original thinking, yet AI is capable of producing content in seconds. How should HR respond to concerns about job security, changing skills and the potential loss of creative opportunities for junior employees?
I think we need to be honest that AI will inevitably change the shape of most industries. In response, HR teams should help leaders understand what that means for the skills required, while helping employees understand what could change in their roles and how they can prepare for it.
For businesses committed to developing junior talent, there’s an opportunity to use the time AI saves deliberately. If research and first drafts take less time, junior colleagues could get earlier exposure to strategic planning, client conversations and new business pitches, supported by coaching and meaningful responsibility to build those capabilities.
We still need people who can recognise a strong idea, challenge a weak one and understand why something will resonate with an audience. That judgement develops through hands-on experience, so we need to preserve opportunities to build it at every level. Otherwise, we risk creating a workforce of human AI agents passing on outputs they haven’t learned to question.
What do you think employers most frequently misunderstand about retaining talented people, particularly those who are ambitious but may not want to move into management?
I think employers too often treat management as the natural reward for being good at a job. Giving excellent practitioners that significant, often time-consuming, responsibility without the interest or support to succeed can eventually cost you both the person and members of their team.
I appreciate the structural challenge, particularly in agencies. You need people to manage teams and take on greater commercial responsibility, as well as a consistent career framework to help everyone understand how progression works in the context of your business. But there needs to be enough flexibility to recognise where people contribute most by asking what they want from their career and being clear about how their expertise, influence and pay could develop accordingly. A role that gives someone meaningful scope to use their strengths makes staying more compelling and finding something comparable elsewhere more difficult.
It also makes workforce planning more honest. Once you understand what your existing team can and wants to do, you can identify the management, commercial or generalist skills you need to hire. Otherwise, assuming everyone will develop equally via a rigid career pathway can leave you with gaps that only become obvious when someone is struggling in a role they never wanted.
PHA offers enhanced parental benefits, including up to 26 weeks of full maternity and adoption pay. What more should employers be doing to prevent parenthood and caring responsibilities from becoming barriers to career progression?
Enhanced parental pay can make a real difference during periods of parental leave, but preventing parenthood from becoming a career barrier means looking at what happens before leave and after someone returns. Support might start with fertility treatment, pregnancy loss or health conditions people are managing while considering a family. Equally, returning from parental leave shouldn’t mean having to prove your ambition again, particularly when the financial responsibilities of parenthood can make career progression even more important.
Flexibility is an obvious starting point, but how the role is adapted determines whether it works. If someone reduces their hours, which responsibilities change, how are performance expectations adjusted and how is anyone taking on the additional work supported and recognised? Offering flexibility achieves little if someone ends up doing the same work for less pay or finds the arrangement held against them when promotion is discussed.
Support also needs to extend beyond parents to people caring for an elderly parent, a disabled partner or someone else who depends on them. Many won’t identify as carers because they see those responsibilities as simply being part of a family or relationship, so employers need to make clear who can access support, without relying on people to recognise themselves in a policy title, and ensure using it doesn’t limit their career opportunities. This is where clear job descriptions, meaningful appraisals and consistent promotion reviews matter, keeping decisions focused on someone’s contribution rather than assumptions about their availability or ambition.
“HR’s value will increasingly come from how well we exercise judgement, rather than how much we can manage ourselves.”
How comfortable are you challenging the CEO or other senior executives when you believe a commercial decision could have damaging consequences for employees?
I’ve found that senior leaders genuinely want to understand the consequences of their decisions for employees, which makes me feel comfortable in sharing my perspective when needed. We share the objective of making decisions that make commercial sense, and it’s my role to bring the employee perspective into that discussion early enough to influence the approach.
When I need to raise an alternative perspective, I focus on explaining who would be affected, the likely consequences and what we could do differently. Sometimes the decision itself is sound, but the reasoning needs clearer communication. Leaders have often spent weeks discussing something employees are hearing for the first time, so HR can help bridge that gap by anticipating questions, making sure managers understand the rationale and giving employees at all levels a consistent explanation.
Many organisations have invested heavily in employee wellbeing programmes, yet stress and burnout remain persistent problems. Are employers sometimes treating the symptoms rather than addressing the working conditions that cause them?
Yes, in some cases. I also think employers sometimes mistake participation in a wellbeing programme for evidence that people are well. A smaller budget can actually prompt a more useful conversation as when another initiative isn’t an option, there’s more reason to examine what’s causing the pressure and what could change in the working day to reduce it.
Support also needs to keep pace with how people work. Many initiatives introduced during the pandemic addressed isolation, reduced opportunities to exercise and the adjustment to working from home. Those needs haven’t disappeared, but employers should question whether the same offering still fits. That means looking at everyday working conditions alongside individual support. Better resourcing, fewer unnecessary meetings and making sure people can take breaks and annual leave can ease pressure across a team.
Regardless, HR needs to retain an awareness that two colleagues with similar workloads may be managing very different circumstances. One might benefit from support from an Employee Assistance Programme, while another needs a temporary change to their working pattern. Being fair doesn’t mean offering everyone an identical solution, it means making support accessible, considering requests consistently and checking that an adjustment genuinely helps without leaving someone else with an unsustainable workload.
And finally, how do you see HR evolving over the next five years?
Over the next five years, I think HR’s value will increasingly come from how well we exercise judgement, rather than how much we can manage ourselves. I expect AI to become more embedded in smaller People teams like ours, moving beyond drafting and administration into recommendations about recruitment, performance and workforce planning. Who knows how far that will go. But we’ll need the confidence and knowledge to question it. A pattern in the data doesn’t explain someone’s circumstances, and an apparently objective recommendation can still reinforce bias.
Government decisions about employment law will also shape the future of HR. I expect more of what was considered good practice to become a formal obligation, so People teams will need to become better at anticipating that direction, preparing managers and improving working practices before a deadline forces the issue. For me, progress would mean HR spending less time managing the consequences of decisions it wasn’t involved in and more time helping the business make better ones.