Should business be forced by government to disclose how much employees earn?

-

Marco Rubio, one of the leading candidates running for the Republican nomination in the United States
Marco Rubio, one of the leading candidates running for the Republican nomination in the United States

In the United States President Obama recently announced that the American government will be collecting detailed salary data by race and gender for every business in the country with more than 100 employees.

Although the move is good spirited and has been designed to try and reduce the gender pay gap, the policy, which has been enforced not by a Congressional vote but by executive order, does have the potential to cause some problems.

For a start it could prompt a bonanza of frivolous race and sex-discrimination lawsuits in an American legal system that already has its fair share of those to deal with. There is of course also the concern that this is just another case of government pushing its nose into private business, a place where it is not often welcome.

The decision by the president will help to push the spotlight onto some sections of American business that have been notoriously uneven for decades, Silicon Valley for example. 82 percent of Google’s engineering positions are filled by men, of whom 35 percent are Asian-American and 59 percent are white.

HRreview Logo

Get our essential weekday HR news and updates.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Keep up with the latest in HR...
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
Optin_date
This field is hidden when viewing the form

 

Up until quite recently Apple had an executive team that was exclusively composed of white men, despite having its headquarters in a county in which only 17 percent of people are white men.

Silicon Valley is without a doubt ashamed of its lack of diversity. It is home to many contributors to Senator Bernie Sanders presidential campaign, a man who is firmly in favour of equality in the workplace.

So far the Republican candidates running for president, have, surprisingly shown little interest in attaching the president’s new policy. Although this truce is unlikely to last long. Republicans notoriously dislike the government playing any kind of role in private business, so the knives will no doubt be out for this policy soon.

What is even more surprising is that the Conservative Government in the UK is about to roll out a similar policy, which is a good example of how the right wing of American and British politics differ.

Robert joined the HRreview editorial team in October 2015. After graduating from the University of Salford in 2009 with a BA in Politics, Robert has spent several years working in print and online journalism in Manchester and London. In the past he has been part of editorial teams at Flux Magazine, Mondo*Arc Magazine and The Marine Professional.

Latest news

Aon’s – 2026 Human Capital Trends Study

This study, based on Aon’s 2026 Human Capital Trends Survey and insights from human capital specialists, equips senior leaders with the perspective needed to navigate this shift and unlock sustainable growth.

Menopause support gaps push women out of jobs as ‘masking’ takes toll

Women consider leaving jobs as menopause symptoms go unsupported, with many hiding their condition at work.

Workers ‘ignore AI tools and stick with manual tasks’ despite heavy investment

Employees are avoiding workplace AI tools and reverting to manual tasks, raising concerns about trust, usability and the value of tech investment.

Victor Riparbelli on AI boosting the value of people

“AI will make great human communicators even more valuable than before.”
- Advertisement -

Up to 28,000 employees affected by paper-based data breaches

Thousands of workers affected by paper-based data incidents as organisations miss reporting deadlines and overlook offline risks.

Helen Wada: Why engagement initiatives fail without human-centric leadership

Workforce engagement has become a hot topic across the boardroom and beyond, particularly as hybrid working practices have become the norm.

Must read

Helen Bailey: Beyond International Women’s Day: leadership ideas that stick

International Women’s Day may have come and gone, but the key message of supporting women to progress and develop into top leadership positions remains as a priority for many organisations.

Rebecca Clarke: Why is Donald Trump telling his staff what to wear at work?

It is a well known story that former President...
- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you