Former employee challenges zero hours contract

-

contractA former employee of Sports Direct has launched legal action against the firm over its use of zero hours contracts in a case that could have serious implications for a huge number of employees across the country who are currently employed on zero hours contracts.

Zahera Gabriel-Abraham has brought the legal claim, which is funded by fellow members of 38 Degrees (one of the UK’s biggest campaigning communities) through donations.

She started working at the Croydon Sports Direct store in October 2012 as a part-time sales assistant, and similarly to all of the company’s part-time sales assistants she was termed a “casual” worker.

Gabriel-Abraham claims that, despite the “casual” label, the reality of her working arrangement should have entitled her to be treated no less favourably than full-time employees.

HRreview Logo

Get our essential weekday HR news and updates.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Keep up with the latest in HR...
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
Optin_date
This field is hidden when viewing the form

 

Commenting, she said:

“If you happen to fall out of line, or your manager thinks you have not done very well that week, your hours just get cut – you feel like you are just at the beck and call of the people above you.

“I felt I always had to play up to someone’s ego just to work – and in the end you just start to feel a bit bullied.”

She added:

“Regularly they would call you in the middle of the day and they are like: ‘Can you come to work now?’ You feel like you have to say yes because if you say no you are seen as unreliable and the next week you don’t get a shift, it is as simple as that.

“I felt hugely manipulated and bullied the whole time.”

It was recently revealed that Sports Direct employs 20,000 of its 23,000 employees under the zero hours contracts, and since then, a number of other employers have admitted that they also employ a large number of workers on such contracts.

Elizabeth George, a barrister at Leigh Day, who is acting for Gabriel-Abraham, said:

“We are not arguing that employers cannot have genuine flexible contracts, but the contract under which Ms Gabriel-Abraham worked, and which all SportsDirect.com 20,000 part-time employees appear to be working, has no flexibility at all for those people who sign them.

“There was no practical difference between the obligations put on my client by the company and those placed on full-time staff.”

She added:

“Casual workers traditionally supplement an employer’s salaried staff, to be called upon when cover is needed or demand is high. In return for not having the security of knowing when you might work, you have the benefit of being able to choose when you work. Without that choice you are not a casual worker, you are just a worker with no job security.

“The ‘casual’ part-time employees in this case are employees in the conventional sense and denying them their paid holidays, sick pay and bonuses is unlawful.”

David Babbs, Executive Director at 38 Degrees, said:

“We’ve had a huge response from our members on this issue, many of whom are on so-called zero-hours contracts themselves.

“These contracts clearly work in certain circumstances, but in others, are being abused by employers to restrict people’s rights. That’s why we’ve asked our members to help fund this legal action – so we can send a clear message to SportsDirect.com that thousands of people are standing with Gabriel-Abraham in her legal claim.”

Mr Babbs added:

“Big businesses must be held to account and zero-hours contracts must not be used as a justification to abuse employees’ rights.”

Latest news

Sustainable business starts with people, not HR policies

Why long-term success depends on supporting employees, not just meeting ESG targets, with practical steps for leaders to build healthier organisations.

Hiring steadies but Gulf crisis threatens recovery in UK jobs market

UK hiring shows signs of stabilising, but rising global uncertainty linked to the Gulf crisis is weighing on employer confidence and delaying recovery.

Women ‘face career setback’ risk with flexible working

Female staff using remote or reduced-hour arrangements more likely to move into lower-status roles, raising concerns about bias in career progression.

Jo Kansagra: Make work benefits work for Gen Z

Gen Z employees are entering the workforce at full steam, and yet many workplace benefits schemes are firmly stuck in the past.
- Advertisement -

Union access plans risk straining workplace relations, CIPD warns

Proposed rules on workplace access raise concerns about employer readiness and operational strain.

Petra Wilton on managers struggling with new workplace laws

“Managers are not being given the tools they need to fully understand how the rules of the workplace are changing.”

Must read

Ally Fekaiki: Employee benefits: how to fix the one common HR practice employees hate

Employee benefits famously a pain point for HRs and hated by employees. Amidst record level vacancies, they've also become key ammunition to entice talent, with companies constantly announcing new perks.

Joe Rafferty: Can You Handle The Truth?

“I have to; celebrate you baby, I have to praise...
- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you