Depressed employee sues company for deducting sick pay

-

A mother-of-two, who became depressed when her husband announced he was gay, has successfully sued her employers for refusing her sick pay during her time off work with depression.

Olga Gofmane, a manager of one of Holland and Barrett’s branches, was signed off work by her doctor, but she received wages of just £1.50 a month after the company deducted sick pay.

She sued the company for breach of contract, and the tribunal at Reading, heard how Mrs Gofmane had been diagnosed with clinical depression after the breakdown of her marriage.

Mrs Gofmane told an employment tribunal:

HRreview Logo

Get our essential weekday HR news and updates.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Keep up with the latest in HR...
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
Optin_date
This field is hidden when viewing the form

 

“To the latter part of 2011 I had to deal with extremely difficult personal circumstances and consequently I started to become physically and mentally unwell.”

It was revealed that initially she remained at work because she had to support herself and her children, but her unfortunate situation at home led to her making mistakes at work and her line managers launched a disciplinary procedure.

In addition to this, they criticised her over an alleged unauthorised absence when she took a Saturday off because her daughter was ill, despite her stating she had texted her area manager to alert her.

On visiting a doctor on March 20 2012, she was advised to stop working immediately and was signed off.

When she received her pay slip for April, Mrs Gofmane found that her sick pay had been deducted, despite the company paying statutory sick pay.

She told the Court:

“I rang the HR department the same day. I was sure it was a mistake. I was at my wits’ end and totally distressed at the prospect of not having my salary.

“I’m a single mother with two children, with rent and bills and food to buy and was totally panicking as to how I would manage financially.”

The panel also heard that she had to get an emergency loan from a friend in Switzerland and also went back to work early, against her doctor’s advice.

Holland and Barrett later paid the money, following a grievance brought by Mrs Gofmane, but the tribunal has now ruled that their actions were in breach of the contract.

The judge ordered the company to pay the £77.40 Mrs Gofmane incurred in arranging the loan from her friend.

At the same hearing the firm was acquitted of any disability discrimination against its employee, who had alleged she was unfairly treated because of her mental health problems.

Judge Russell Hardwick accepted the argument of Mrs Gofmane’s regional manager, in which it was reported that she had suspended the worker because of her not adhering to company rules on reporting absence.

The judge stated the evidence of her having a disability was ‘scant’ and that even if they had considered that her mental health problems were a disability, Holland and Barrett was unaware of it at the time it instigated disciplinary proceedings and stopped her pay.

Latest news

England’s overnight World Cup clash and 5am pub opening prompt CIPD advice

The CIPD is urging organisations to agree any flexibility before England's 1am World Cup last-16 tie to help minimise disruption at the start of the working week.

Russell Cowley: Gen Z – rebuilding workplace culture, break by break

Gen Z workers are taking proper breaks and in doing so, they may be fixing something the rest of us broke.

Fit for Work: Weekend warrior? You can still reap the health benefits

Weekend exercise can still improve long-term health, even for people who struggle to fit physical activity into the working week.

Superdry co-founder’s victim warns workplace power can silence abuse victims

A survivor's account raises questions about speaking-up cultures and accountability in organisations.
- Advertisement -

UK’s always-on work culture ‘driving employee burnout’

Nearly half of UK workers say they end most working days mentally exhausted as rising workplace pressure leaves employees and managers struggling to switch off.

Andrew Murray on why no two days look alike

A people development leader shares how travel, training and a passion for helping others shape a working day with little room for routine.

Must read

Pay-for-Performance and the Science Behind What Motivates Us

Talent professionals sometimes think that potential new hires will simply follow the money, and therefore a dollar amount is everything. But what if this model for compensation is misaligned with what employees really value?

Richard Evens: Maintaining a safe working environment with rising summer temperatures

With much of the cold weather giving way to...
- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you