Appraisals going out of fashion as employees left wanting for constructive criticism

-

The opera house in Copenhagen. Constructive criticism is generally not something missing in the theatre, but in the workplace appraisals are not happening as often as they used to. Image: Henning Larsen Architects
The opera house in Copenhagen. Constructive criticism is generally not something missing in the theatre, but in the workplace appraisals are not happening as often as they used to. Image: Henning Larsen Architects

The theatre is not a place that wants for criticism. Reviews of performances come in thick and fast and when praise is due it often gushes, and in similar fashion, when something is judged to be terrible, the poison pours. Performers, in some cases, use reviews to hone and better their performance.

An appraisal is the employee’s version of an actor’s review, but unlike the review, appraisals in the workplace are becoming less common. They have traditionally always been a yearly occasion that often provokes dread in the hours and days before they occur.

Year long wait

New research released by Enterprise Study found that one-in-five staff employed for longer than a year said they have yet to experience their first annual review.

HRreview Logo

Get our essential weekday HR news and updates.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Keep up with the latest in HR...
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
Optin_date
This field is hidden when viewing the form

 

Of those employees who had been lucky enough to undergo an appraisal, 43 percent had to request it themselves, with 27 percent having to wait more than six months to have it after the request was made.

Postponed 

The report also investigated the reasons why appraisals were being postponed. Managers ‘being too busy’ was the principal reason (38 per cent), while only 57 percent of staff said their managers had opted to take the initiative and schedule an appraisal themselves.

It also became apparent in the study that some employers believe that if their company is small and informal then a structured appraisal process is not required. Many HR managers would, no doubt, disagree.

Robert joined the HRreview editorial team in October 2015. After graduating from the University of Salford in 2009 with a BA in Politics, Robert has spent several years working in print and online journalism in Manchester and London. In the past he has been part of editorial teams at Flux Magazine, Mondo*Arc Magazine and The Marine Professional.

Latest news

Dr. Poornima Luthra: What HR leaders should, and shouldn’t, say in moments of societal crisis

Times of social tension offer an opportunity for learning and growth, for fostering truly inclusive workplaces, if approached intentionally.

BBC job cuts ‘risk legal fallout’ if consultation and communication fall short

Legal experts warn large-scale redundancies must follow strict consultation rules as employers face rising financial pressures and workforce scrutiny.

CIPD appoints Neil Carberry as chief executive amid ‘new era of work’

New leadership announced at the UK’s professional body for HR as organisations prepare for rapid changes in work, skills and technology.

NDA clampdown planned as government targets workplace harassment cover-ups

Government plans to curb misuse of confidentiality clauses aim to stop workers being silenced over harassment and discrimination.
- Advertisement -

‘Nearly half’ of UK workers fear robots could replace their jobs

Security risks emerge as the biggest concern about workplace automation.

Britain now an ‘overqualified nation’ with millions stuck in dead-end jobs

Millions of graduates are stuck in low-progression roles as rising qualification levels outpace the number of jobs that fully use their skills.

Must read

Jo Stubbs: Managing a fair redundancy selection process

Jo Stubbs provides expert advice to employers and HR professionals on how to manage a fair redundency selection and how to navigate around unfair dismissals.

Helen Burgess: Sexual harassment at work

The recent allegations of harassment raised by the Williams’ former PA and house manager and claims that the army needs to do more to stamp it out have brought to the fore discussions on sexual harassment in the workplace.  So what are the implications for ’ordinary’ employers?
- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you