Critics brand Lord Sugar’s apprentice scheme a gimmick

-

HR jobs market increases for the first time since FebruaryThe website launched by the government and backed by Lord Alan Sugar has filled a reporter 1,185 vacancies out of 18,000 available. Critics are calling it a failure, with the conservative branding it an “expensive gimmick”.

Lord Sugar launched the National Apprenticeship Matching Service earlier this year, with TV ads and the support of the government which made Sugar a peer and government enterprise tsar.

The scheme cost a reported £2.85m in advertising in 2008-2009, with additional efforts planned to fund an extra 35,000 apprenticeships to help tackle the recession.

Substantial increases have been reported, however. In June, only 616 apprenticeship vacancies had been filled out out of 17,788 advertised, and the National Apprenticeship Service said that the numbers of vacancies would take time as more students reach the end of their courses.

HRreview Logo

Get our essential weekday HR news and updates.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Keep up with the latest in HR...
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
Optin_date
This field is hidden when viewing the form

 

More adults over the age of 25 are now considering apprenticeships, with the amounts of over 25 taking up the scheme increasing fourfold.

Shadow higher education spokesman David Willetts said: “Apprenticeships are an excellent way to help the young victims of Labour’s recession, but the government is failing to provide the real help needed.

“Instead of celebrity gimmicks like this, the government should be funding apprenticeship places and making it easier for businesses to run the schemes.”

A spokeswoman for the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills said: “The purpose of the Apprenticeship Vacancies system is to allow employers to advertise vacancies for free and potential apprentices anywhere in the country to see what is available and apply online.

“The system is successfully attracting employers and potential apprentices.

“The real measure of the success of apprenticeships is that 225,000 people started one in 2007-08 compared to only 65,000 in 1996-97; and successful completion rates have risen to 64%.”

talentpagebanner

Paul Gray is an entrepreneur and digital publisher who creates online publications focused on solving problems, delivering news, and providing platforms for informed comment and debate. He is associated with HRZone and has built businesses in the HR and professional publishing sector. His work emphasizes creating industry-specific content platforms.

Latest news

Menopause support gaps push women out of jobs as ‘masking’ takes toll

Women consider leaving jobs as menopause symptoms go unsupported, with many hiding their condition at work.

Workers ‘ignore AI tools and stick with manual tasks’ despite heavy investment

Employees are avoiding workplace AI tools and reverting to manual tasks, raising concerns about trust, usability and the value of tech investment.

Victor Riparbelli on AI boosting the value of people

“AI will make great human communicators even more valuable than before.”

Up to 28,000 employees affected by paper-based data breaches

Thousands of workers affected by paper-based data incidents as organisations miss reporting deadlines and overlook offline risks.
- Advertisement -

Helen Wada: Why engagement initiatives fail without human-centric leadership

Workforce engagement has become a hot topic across the boardroom and beyond, particularly as hybrid working practices have become the norm.

Recruiters warned to move beyond ‘post and pray’ as passive talent overlooked

Employers risk missing most candidates by relying on job boards as hiring methods struggle to deliver quality applicants.

Must read

Garry Goldman: Is hybrid working hindering younger employees?

With hybrid working now a permanent fixture in many organisations, how can employers ensure younger people in particular are supported, especially on days when they are working remotely?

Simon Ashton: How should leaders use neuroscience in their leadership development?

The 18th-21nd November was International Leadership Week.
- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you