Lucinda Bromfield: Is box ticking a thing of the past ?

-

If you want to hire someone out of the ordinary, look for someone out of the ordinary. Sounds trite, but in a world of ever more structured demands being put on applicants for jobs, it seems that the out of the ordinary is more and more unusual.

Some of the most effective people I come across have come from unusual backgrounds for the work they do. They may have had previous careers, or a career break to bring up a family or recover from an illness. Perhaps they went back to school, or retrained for a new role later in life.

Of course, I’m not talking about jobs for which you need specific qualifications or expertise. Those boxes absolutely must be ticked. But though I hear people trumpeting the value of transferable skills and alternative experience, I seldom see them thinking about their hiring decisions in that way. They usually have a fairly fixed idea of what they are looking for and readily discount candidates who don’t fit the mould.

Partly this is caused by sheer number of applicants – you have to be able to decide a short list somehow. And partly it is caused by the sheer plethora of qualifications out there – it can be hard to tell one from another in some cases. And lastly, in some cases it is caused by fixed ideas, time pressure and the desire to get someone who is a ‘safe bet’.

HRreview Logo

Get our essential weekday HR news and updates.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Keep up with the latest in HR...
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
Optin_date
This field is hidden when viewing the form

 

But it is worth thinking about your hiring decisions in the wider context of your business. By increasing the diversity of your organisation you can benefit from different viewpoints which often lead to different (and potentially better) solutions. With the current emphasis on equal opportunities and the aging workforce, there is more legal and societal pressure than ever before to consider all candidates on their merits, and to look at what they can bring to a role rather than whether they fit pre-selected criteria.

I’m not saying don’t look for great academics, or don’t have basics on which you insist, like decent grammar, spelling and numeracy. But if you open your mind to some more unlikely candidates, you may find you’ve got so much more than your boxes ticked.

‘This information is believed to be correct as of the date published. It is not a substitute for legal advice and no liability attaches to its use. Specific and personal legal advice should be taken on any individual matter’.

Lucinda Bromfield, Employment Specialist, Bevans Solicitors

Lucinda Bromfield is an employment specialist at Bevans, advising on all aspects of employment law and alternative dispute resolution. Before becoming a solicitor she had experience of working in compliance and HR for large private and public sector organizations. She is a qualified mediator and has a particular interest in the role of effective communication and HR in building sustainable, profitable businesses.

Latest news

Vacancies rise but UK jobs market remains near five-year lows as salaries pass £44,000

UK hiring shows modest improvement as pay rises continue, but job competition remains high and entry-level opportunities stay limited.

Jo Kansagra: How business can get 20% more out of their employees

Stress is more than a wellbeing concern. When employees are burnt out, overwhelmed, and excessively busy it harms their motivation and productivity.

Is working from home really a career killer?

Jennifer Liston-Smith’s reflections on leadership, work-life blend and the meaning of work. With fierce debate for and against working from...

Aon’s – 2026 Human Capital Trends Study

This study, based on Aon’s 2026 Human Capital Trends Survey and insights from human capital specialists, equips senior leaders with the perspective needed to navigate this shift and unlock sustainable growth.
- Advertisement -

Menopause support gaps push women out of jobs as ‘masking’ takes toll

Women consider leaving jobs as menopause symptoms go unsupported, with many hiding their condition at work.

Workers ‘ignore AI tools and stick with manual tasks’ despite heavy investment

Employees are avoiding workplace AI tools and reverting to manual tasks, raising concerns about trust, usability and the value of tech investment.

Must read

Chris Townsend: Apprenticeships in the UK – ABM case study

On National Apprenticeships Week we bring you company case studies to inspire you!

An external approach: how to retain your staff

As part of the build up to October’s Employee...
- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you