HR industry “wasting” £9bn on recruitment

-

HR teams are being accused of using outdated and ineffective methods to hire employees, while wasting money on recruitment costs.

A study by the acquisition platform TalentTrack, says firms are in a “hiring frenzy” since the end of the pandemic, the Great Resignation, and Brexit.

It estimates that 11 per cent of people who were in work twelve months ago will have changed jobs, with a higher salary. It says there have been approximately 4,1 million job hires between September 2021 and 2021, at an estimated recruitment cost of around £18.5bn on recruitment, with the problem expected to get worse.

ONS Figures

Meanwhile, latest ONS figures show the number of payrolled employees has increased for the sixth consecutive month, but are still below pre-covid levels.

Get our essential weekday HR news and updates.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Keep up with the latest in HR...
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
Optin_date
This field is hidden when viewing the form

 

In response to these figures, James Reed, chairman of REED, said:

“This ongoing rise in job vacancies is a positive sign of the economy’s continued revival. Rapid job creation means there are plenty of opportunities to go around, and not just for those recently off furlough, but also for others who have faced long or short-term unemployment as well as those already in work who are seeking a new challenge.”

The ONS also admits things are picking up, saying:

“The number of job vacancies in March to May 2021 was 758,000, only 27,000 below the level before the coronavirus pandemic in January to March 2020. Most industries have recovered to show vacancies above pre-pandemic levels.”

The workforce can afford to be “picky” about roles

Recently, recruiter Randstad UK suggested almost one in four workers are planning a job change and that 69 per cent of workers are now confident about finding another role.

Mark Taylor, chief executive of TalentTrack said: “Due to the intense competition for skilled workers, candidates in some sectors are being offered pay increases of up to 20 per cent to switch jobs.  To add insult to injury, that is driving up the cost of hiring recruitment consultancies, who typically charge 15 to 25 per cent of salary.”

Mark Taylor, CEO TalentTrack         Photographer: Jason Alden

James Reed agrees, but sees this as a positive and a way to improve staff wellbeing:

” The end of furlough may have given employers a boost. However, in order to attract and retain the top talent in a crowded labour market, many businesses will need to improve working conditions – including offering flexible working arrangements which have been popularised since the start of the pandemic – as well as offering more competitive salaries.”

This site has reported previously that employers are improving job quality and raising wages to either help with recruitment or try to keep current staff from leaving.

Advice from recruitment firms:

James Reed said the government’s relaxing of visa restrictions is a positive, especially for those areas that need workers. But he warns: “However, a long-term strategy to reskill and upskill our domestic workforce for the jobs of the future is also necessary.”

Mark Taylor called on HR teams to look at the systems they’re using, calling the current methods “outdated”.

He said: “It’s like trying to win a game of tennis playing with a frying pan.  That has implications for employers and the country – the economy is suffering because of UK plc’s outdated approach to recruitment.”

His advice for HR teams is to post jobs on a variety of jobs at the same time, while they ensure the hiring methods used are efficient.

He said: ” Analyse the source of every recent hire, combining payroll data with other internal records to identify the best and worst employees in terms of ability and retention, in order to better target media spend – and thereby save their organisation money.  AI is now perfectly capable of doing this.  Our most conservative estimate is that an HR team can halve the cost of finding new hires as a result. ”

 

Feyaza Khan has been a journalist for more than 20 years in print and broadcast. Her special interests include neurodiversity in the workplace, tech, diversity, trauma and wellbeing.

Latest news

Personalising the Benefits Experience: Why Employees Need More Than Just Information

This article explores how organisations can move beyond passive, one-size-fits-all communication to deliver relevant, timely, and simplified benefits experiences that reflect employee needs and life stages.

Grant Wyatt: When the love dies – when staying is riskier than quitting

When people fall out of love with their employer, or feel their employer has fallen out of love with them, what follows is rarely a clean exit.

£30bn pension savings window opens for employers ahead of 2029 reforms

UK employers could unlock billions in National Insurance savings by expanding pension salary sacrifice schemes before new limits take effect in 2029.

Expat jobs ‘fail early as costs hit $79,000 per worker’

International assignments are ending early due to family strain, isolation and poor preparation, as rising costs increase pressure on employers.
- Advertisement -

The Great Employer Divide: What the evidence shows about employers that back parents and carers — and those that don’t

Understand the growing divide between organisations that effectively support working parents and carers — and those that don’t. This session shows how to turn employee experience data into a clear business case, linking care-related pressures to performance, retention and workforce stability.

Scott Mills exit puts spotlight on risk of ‘news vacuum’ in high-profile dismissals

Sudden departure of a long-serving BBC presenter raises questions about how employers manage high-profile dismissals and limit speculation.

Must read

Dean Ball: How to win the war for talent with weird interview questions

The average HR professional conducts numerous interviews each year,...

Nestlé UK Walks its Way to a Healthier Future

Nestlé UK has always had a well developed Occupational Health and Safety program. However, in line with a business transition from a Food and Beverage manufacturer to a focused Health, Nutrition and Wellness business, over the last 12 months, Nestlé have transitioned OH towards a more integrated “employee wellness” scheme that impacts ALL of its 6,000 employees in the UK. Dr David Batman explains more.
- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you