Ania Krasniewska on Human Quotas

-

“This kind of change will be legislation driven.”

Context

At a recent HR event in London, one theme dominated discussion: the idea of “human quotas” — legal requirements for minimum levels of human involvement in work as artificial intelligence transforms production and decision-making.

Ania Krasniewska, group vice president at research and advisory firm Gartner, said that while many workplace revolutions have been led by corporate strategy, this one will come from above. “This kind of change won’t be organizationally driven; it will be legislation driven,” she said in an interview with news site Business Insider at the Gartner HR Symposium.

Analysts at advisory firm Gartner predicted that by 2032, at least 30 percent of the world’s top economies will introduce certified human quotas. These measures would ensure that people remain meaningfully involved in creative and operational processes even as AI systems take on more of the workload.

Meaning

Krasniewska’s comments reflect a growing recognition that, without regulatory boundaries, automation could marginalise human workers across sectors. The concept of “human in the loop” — requiring people to oversee and correct AI decisions — is already embedded in the European Union’s AI Act, which mandates human oversight for high-risk systems.

Get our essential weekday HR news and updates.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Keep up with the latest in HR...
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
Optin_date
This field is hidden when viewing the form

 

She pointed to a recent Australian High Court ruling as a possible precedent. The court found that employers must consider redeploying staff before outsourcing or restructuring, a principle that could extend to how businesses balance AI and human work in future.

Implications

If governments adopt human quotas, HR departments will need robust systems to document where and how human oversight occurs. Krasniewska said businesses may have to “prove they’re doing it”, requiring new audit trails, disclosures and reporting standards.

Such regulation could increase compliance costs for firms but also reinforce the value of human judgment, especially in areas like healthcare, law and data management, where accountability is critical.

It may represent a safeguard for employees, against full automation, ensuring that human skill and intuition remain embedded in decision-making processes.

As AI integration accelerates, Krasniewska’s warning is that future workforce policy will not be left to corporate goodwill. It will be written into law.

William Furney is a Managing Editor at Black and White Trading Ltd based in Kingston upon Hull, UK. He is a prolific author and contributor at Workplace Wellbeing Professional, with over 127 published posts covering HR, employee engagement, and workplace wellbeing topics. His writing focuses on contemporary employment issues including pension schemes, employee health, financial struggles affecting workers, and broader workplace trends.

Latest news

Transgender staff excluded from single-sex toilets under new equality guidance

Transgender people must be excluded from single-sex toilets and changing rooms that correspond with their lived gender under updated...

Simon Coker: Closing the emotional gap – why AI in the workplace is as much a human challenge as a technological one

AI adoption is transforming how work gets done across every sector. But its deeper impact is less visible: it is reshaping how people feel about their work.

Employment tribunal delays stretch towards 2030 as lawyers warn system is nearing collapse

Employment tribunal hearings are being delayed for years as lawyers warn mounting backlogs are undermining workplace justice.

Keeping culture and purpose at the centre of a growing fintech

A fintech people leader explains how culture, wellbeing and purpose are being protected during rapid business growth.
- Advertisement -

Migrant worker with no right to work in UK wins discrimination case against employer

An employment tribunal has ruled that a migrant worker without the legal right to work in Britain can still pursue successful discrimination claims.

Government to replace some GP sick notes with return-to-work plans

Workers in four English regions will be directed towards personalised health and employment support as ministers test alternatives to GP-issued fit notes.

Must read

Southard Jones: Reading the data tea leaves – can HR help predict future business success?

Last year, Towers Watson found that one in three organisations planned to increase spend on their HR function by more than 20 percent, and HR data and analytics tools rated as one of the top areas for investment. However, just looking at HR data in isolation does not represent the best opportunity to make an impact.

Anne Allen: Why every HR team needs to be replaced by a “People Experience” team

Companies often cite people as their most valuable asset, yet don’t take a people-centric approach when it comes to planning and organising for success. Anne Allen discusses how best to take this approach.
- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you