Maggie Berry:How collective responsibility can create a better working environment

-

I was recently surprised to read statistics claiming that more than two fifths of men would ‘prefer’ to work in an environment of ‘just male employees’ while only 8% of the men think a women-only office would be ideal for them.

According to HR consultancy Reabur, who conducted the online poll, 64% of men who wanted to work in an all-male workplace put this down to a ‘bitchy environment’ created by ‘some female colleagues’.

These statistics, if accurate, are somewhat disheartening. It’s a real shame to see that a large proportion of men buy into outmoded stereotypes, not to mention the cliche that a female-dominated office is “bitchy”. It is true to say that there can be tension among competing women in the workplace, but this can also be said of a male attitude to work. This can be indicative of a double standard that’s unfairly placed on women in some industries.

Perhaps more depressingly, of the respondents who stated that they would like to be the only man among female employees, the majority, 68%, said this was down to potential ‘romantic opportunities’ and 11% attributed this to there being ‘less competition’ where female professionals were concerned.

Get our essential weekday HR news and updates.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Keep up with the latest in HR...
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
Optin_date
This field is hidden when viewing the form

 

The most alarming statistic, however, is that the majority of female respondents (59%), said that they would prefer work in male-dominated workplace. Of this figure, 34% believed this would “reduce the bitchy environment” apparently created by women.

While the proportion of women who felt this way was significantly lower than men, it’s still unfortunate that, given the potential for support and collaboration between female professionals, so many are put off by the notion that women are “bitchy” or “hostile”.

In the course of my career, I’ve had the good fortune to attend an extremely high number of networking events for women. At these functions I’ve met countless female professionals who have been the polar opposite of “bitchy” or “hostile”. In fact, they have attended solely to support, and be supported by, other women in their careers.

In fact, there are many organisations, Women in Technology included, that have been set up specifically to facilitate this kind of female, professional support and bonding. The stigma of “bitchiness” that has been applied to competitive women must be addressed and removed if there is going to be progress towards gender equality in the workplace – and you only have to attend a women’s networking session to experience this in action.

Outside of these events, there are many ways to highlight how employees, regardless of gender, are collectively responsible for their company culture. If there is a hostile working environment, then company directors need to liaise with HR to see if there’s anything in the corporate values or in the example they set that facilitates this atmosphere. If so, this needs to be addressed and boundaries need to be set from the top down. Team-building activities can also help to break the ice and ease tensions in a difficult situation. They can also help each member of staff to gain a better perspective on their individual contributions to the workplace and can help to counter gender stereotypes.

Statistics of this nature are helpful in understanding the challenges that female professionals face in their careers. While they may seem disheartening, they cut straight to the core of the issue and, in a way, reveal a way forward in creating a better working environment for everyone – and more opportunities for women.

About Maggie Berry

Latest news

Lucy Standing: Older workers are back in the centre of the hiring debate – ready to lead the response?

For HR leaders, the argument is simple: the people being filtered out of your hiring process are not past their best.

One in 10 women quit work after pregnancy loss, report finds

Research suggests inconsistent workplace support following pregnancy loss and maternity leave is contributing to resignations and poorer mental wellbeing.

Fear of becoming obsolete grips workers as AI reshapes careers

More than two in five workers worry their skills could become outdated as AI reshapes hiring demands and increases pressure to keep learning.

Ford rehires 350 engineers after AI fails to deliver

Carmaker says veteran engineers have helped improve quality, mentor younger staff and retrain AI systems after automated checks fell short.
- Advertisement -

Low harassment reporting may hide workplace misconduct, employers warned

Low workplace harassment reporting rates may reflect a lack of trust in reporting systems rather than an absence of misconduct, new research suggests.

Jennifer Liston-Smith joins Halo Workplace Nurseries board

HRreview columnist Jennifer Liston-Smith has joined Halo Workplace Nurseries as chief purpose officer to help develop its workplace nursery compliance platform.

Must read

Nicola McQueen: Skills Shortage – why HR is not to blame?

The much-discussed ‘war for talent’ is continuing to hit the headlines this year as organisations across the UK bear the brunt of industry-wide skills shortages threatening their productivity and growth.

Kevin Dunkeld: Connecting people and business in a sustainable way

What can one company do to connect people and...
- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you